Journal of Social Archaeology · 2021 · 35 citations · 31 references
HumanitiesAnthropologyHistoryBiological AnthropologyIndigenous StudiesPaleobotanyAncient DnaAncient Dna GenomicsGenetic Research EthicsIndigenous ArchaeologyIndigenous Heritage EthicsIndigenous HistoriesAncient Dna EvolutionAncient Dna SequencingAncient Human GenomicsEthical InquiryIndigenous Genomic Research EthicsIndigenous MuseologyScientific Inquiry Understanding
In recent years, the field of paleogenomics has grown into an exciting and rapidly advancing area of scientific inquiry. However, scientific work in this field has far outpaced the discipline’s dialogue about research ethics. In particular, Indigenous peoples have argued that the paleogenomics revolution has produced a “vampire science” that perpetuates biocolonialist traditions of extracting Indigenous bodies and heritage without the consent of, or benefits to, the communities who are most affected by this research. In this article, we explore these ethical issues through the case study of a project that sequenced the ancient DNA (aDNA) of nine Ancestral Puebloan people from Chaco Canyon, New Mexico. By providing a “thick description” of this controversy, we are able to analyze its metanarratives, periodization, path dependency, and historical contingencies. We conclude that the paleogenomics revolution needs to include an ethical revolution that remakes the field’s values, relationships, forms of accountability, and practices.
31
The genome of a Late Pleistocene human from a Clovis burial site in western Montana
Morten Rasmussen, Sarah L. Anzick, Michael R. Waters et al. · Nature · 2014 · 583 citations · Full text
Life Sciences, Archaeology, Genetics +16
“Your DNA Is<i>Our</i>History”
Jenny Reardon, Kim TallBear · Current Anthropology · 2012 · 327 citations
Humanities, Anthropology, History +17
Archaeogenomic evidence reveals prehistoric matrilineal dynasty
Douglas J. Kennett, Stephen Plog, Richard J. George et al. · Nature Communications · 2017 · 311 citations · Full text
Genomic Justice for Native Americans
Nanibaa’ A. Garrison · Science Technology & Human Values · 2012 · 302 citations · Full text
Law, Genetics, Molecular Genetics +17