Regional Science Policy & Practice · 2021 · 15 citations · 28 references
Social SciencesGeographySociologyPopulation GeographySocial GeographyUrban SociologyMetropolitan DemographyNeighborhood DemographyResidential MobilitySocial MobilityUrban Social GeographyEconomic Geography Of InequalityEthnic Residential PatternsEthnic Spatial SegregationMetropolitan CommutingNeighborhood Social CapitalResidential LocationSchool Travel BehaviorSocio-spatial Inequality
This full population study of travel-to-preschool patterns of the youngest children (< 6 years old) in metropolitan Stockholm analyses how school markets, even at an early stage, reproduce inequalities related to social and geographical distances. Our findings show that families with foreign backgrounds tend to convert educational capital into social capital by sending their children to preschools in more socio-economically favourable neighbourhoods. Furthermore, we detect avoidance behaviour among the majority population in ethnically mixed neighbourhoods, which indicate that some native families are inclined to avoid preschools with high shares of non-native peers. Este estudio de la totalidad de la población sobre los patrones de desplazamiento a la escuela para edades preescolares (< 6 años) en el área metropolitana de Estocolmo analiza cómo los mercados escolares, incluso en una etapa temprana, reproducen las desigualdades relacionadas con las distancias sociales y geográficas. Nuestros resultados muestran que las familias de origen extranjero tienden a convertir el capital educativo en capital social enviando a sus hijos a centros de educación preescolar en barrios socioeconómicamente más favorables. Además, se detectaron comportamientos de elusión entre la población mayoritaria de barrios étnicamente mixtos, lo que indica que algunas familias nativas tienden a evitar los centros de preescolar con altos porcentajes de niños no nativos. 今回、ストックホルムの首都圏の幼児(<6歳)の保育施設までの移動パターンの全人口調査を実施し、学校市場が初期の段階においてさえ、どのように社会的および地理的距離に関して不平等を生み出すかを分析した。結果は、外国出身の家族が、社会経済的に恵まれた地域の保育施設に子供を通わせることにより、教育資本を社会資本に転換する傾向があることを示している。さらに、マジョリティの住民には居住者が多民族的な地域を回避する行動があることが検出されたが、これは、ネイティブの家族の一部が、非ネイティブの幼児の割合が高い保育施設を避ける傾向があることを示している。 In the early 1990s, Sweden launched an extensive school reform that paved the way for deregulation, privatization and marketization within the publicly funded school system (Dovemark et al., 2018). Today, the public school system in urban Sweden comprises extensive school markets, offering a large supply of different educational options and providers. This transformation has also turned families into customers who need to develop strategies and take action in all parts of the educational system – all the way from preschool to upper-secondary and adult education. Furthermore, the geography of these urban school markets is structured by the distribution of people's different kinds of resources in social space, making some schools very attractive while others are avoided (cf. Fjellman, 2019; Forsberg, 2018). Alongside family background and economic resources, mobility has become an important aspect of what shapes families' educational strategies, particularly in urban settings (cf. Andersson et al., 2012; Lubienski et al., 2009; Poupeau et al., 2007; Raveaud & van Zanten, 2007). Most studies on this matter pay attention to compulsory or secondary education, while few have examined the expanding preschool sector. In this paper, we analyse the travel-to-school patterns of the youngest children (< 6 years old) in metropolitan Stockholm in order to understand how urban school markets, even at an early stage, shape and reshape social and geographical inequalities. The question in this paper regards what makes parents commute past their closest preschool(s) and have their children attend a preschool further away from home. The Swedish preschool system comprises different types of providers. Public preschools are run by the municipalities and is the most common form of preschools. In addition, there are several types of private providers, who operates with either for-profit or non-profit interests. The former type ranges from preschools of larger for-profit driven business firms to small companies with only one preschool. Among the non-profit providers, parental and staff co-operatives are the most common. In parental co-operatives, it is common that parents share the responsibility for cleaning or help out as staff in various capacities. Parents make up the co-operative that owns the preschool while the staff own and run the staff co-operatives. There are also other forms of non-profit providers such as preschools driven by different types of foundations or congregations. All preschools need to follow the national education act and the curricula for preschools. The difference between the types of preschools, besides the owning arrangements, are the for-profit character of some preschools and the parental involvement in others. It is also common that, especially private, preschools develop pedagogical profiles such as Montessori, Reggio Emilia and others. In this paper we ask how common commuting past the closest preschools is, and to what extent the family's cumulative assets, the preschool's composition of resources and the local preschool market's supply and geographical distribution can explain parts of the variation in urban preschool enrolment. These questions address important aspects of how children's socialization is affected by segregation and by families' educational strategies. For example, Frankenberg et al. (2016) note that preschool children develop racial bias at around the age of five years, and preschool is important for subsequent choices to the compulsory school (Karsten et al., 2003). These individual and societal level consequences of childcare make the preschool sector an important research topic as well as a topic for public debate. Theoretically, we work within a Bourdieusian tradition, focusing on how families' volume and composition of assets are related to their positions and dispositions in social space. In this case, drawing on registry-based data of the total population, we take note of families' composition and volume of educational and economic assets (cf. Bourdieu, 1979). Andersson et al. (2012) identify two important factors for school choice: children's ability to commute, which is associated with costs (money and time), and individuals' socio-economic positions. Furthermore, on a collective analytical level, families are part of larger social groups who occupy different positions in social space. It is conceivable that these different positions lead to different educational strategies (Bourdieu, 1994). At the same time, such strategies are subject to geography with regard to locations, time and distances (Hägerstrand, 1982), especially when it comes to local school markets (Poupeau & François, 2008). In relation to this, we explore the occurrence of white/native avoidance (for a Swedish compulsory school context; see Andersson et al., 2012; Bunar & Kallstenius, 2005). Accordingly, we combine theoretical perspectives from both geography and sociology in order to outline a study that investigates how social groups' assembled assets and social position reflect geographical mobility related to preschool commuting. The study contributes to and complements the international research and debate on school choice by providing a unique insight into school travel and choice among the youngest children. We begin the paper by discussing research on school choice and commuting. Thereafter, we briefly introduce the Swedish preschool system. The analytical strategy, data and variables are presented in the methods section followed by the results section in which we examine commuting to preschools. In a final concluding section, we summarize our findings and discuss policy implications. As far as we know, there is a lack of larger quantitative studies on preschool children's travel-to-preschool patterns. Thus, we will mainly develop our knowledge on school choice and commuting on the basis of research on older children. In research on compulsory school, findings indicate that higher status families are more likely to actively choose schools (Musset, 2012), and that free choice tends to increase segregation (Hsieh & Urquiola, 2006). In contexts where free school choice may influence travel-to-school distance, studies focusing on (spatial) acting capacity are of importance. Andersson et al. (2012) find that the average distance travelled to schools increased over time, but those with foreign background travelled shorter distances, at least those whose parents had less education (see also Bunar & Kallstenius, 2005). They attribute the differences to the possession of spatial capital, which opens up the possibility for some socio-economically more affluent families to commute with their children, or a lack of spatial capital that restricts some families' choice of schools. Commuting may be caused by the desire to send children to high-achievement schools. However, it is to the extent to which high is caused by or by the school and & 2018). that very well in of tend to children from shorter distances, while schools have a geographical of et al., 2007). of is of even more to in preschools. In the of the educational system and the of an extensive reform have the patterns of segregation et al., patterns are also in preschools, even by educational background is even more in preschools on data from one & Forsberg, In relation to the study on preschool and in the of preschool segregation studies (for see & for one important it is important to note the that socio-economic status and educational level have on school choice in Andersson et al., 2012; & et al., 2007). from that, in a preschool of socio-economically take even in a system with high for childcare & with different show a in of segregation for to attend the closest preschool. They also find of among private preschools that there are of choice and even in a system with preschool in a with free some bias is For example, some studies show that parents choose schools by their ability to take out & 2007; 2003). segregation is by patterns. These patterns are on in Sweden as in other 2018). The individual choices of to the of local public This may be an important part of preschool commuting. higher preschools, or preschools by higher are their commuting in this is likely to be However, there be groups that have the economic to find in where their preschool of choice are for these groups commuting is likely that and find that the in preschools segregation in we the of The of and avoidance in relation to segregation in the for and have in school choice the & in & Zanten, In relation to preschools, behaviour children of the majority population to commute to other preschools when the share of children with foreign background increase at the local as in relation to out mobility in the majority population there is an of to the behaviour the composition is and families choose a different preschool to the that the closest preschool will the socio-economic and composition of the We that social and avoidance is a topic to study in the of preschools. We that it is especially to avoidance behaviour in the preschool of the lack of other factors of the social and background factors to be at the of the of white/native and There is also a that families will choose the closest preschool to make their as as However, other aspects influence the preschool work related arrangements, and a lack of preschool at the closest preschool. the data for our we for parents who to understand how these factors family's preschool choice other type of data and are in Sweden is publicly funded and to from small children to attend preschool between the of the age of children are to a in a preschool and from the age of families have the to a of of childcare to public children in the Swedish preschool system in which is to of all children pay a for their children in preschool. The between municipalities but is by by The The and of preschool to some extent between the The system for public preschools also the majority of preschools. In the of several from The preschool which the in most Swedish In the system parents are to preschools in order of and with other on time in the and is to in the children with children at of the at the age of children with in the same and a older children have over children. private preschools their own a system on time in up a preschool less a In some this lead to for some type of preschools. For private preschool providers in high status in order to avoid social that be for their the Swedish preschool system the majority of children and is publicly the system is on and preschool providers need to to and to by and This paper with preschool commuting in metropolitan We make of a of the data from Sweden in the at on family background and preschool for all children between the of one and In the data children. The a of economic and educational variables for parents and the geographical of preschools and of children and their families a by The data in Stockholm of which attend – as Stockholm with There are some with data on Swedish preschool children in the years we data from which the possibility to the of the patterns Our is on in preschools, we very small the data it is to a at a preschool an choice by the parents or a by a lack of local preschool The may parents to commute with their children to to a preschool. However, the data to study and preschool making it to out larger aspects of preschool and geographical distances between and preschool. Andersson et al. we are distance, but we distance in we a by preschool choices by distance from home. The of distance are on where preschools are and where children However, the is by it is to have several preschools as the The the of the closest preschools on the distance between We distance to the closest preschools, our has a of All of children preschools further away are these are likely to children where are for in the where the parents are Our show the extent to which preschool commuting is by the families' assets, preschool and which makes it to a of factors preschool and in what shapes preschool We the of variables on the a the is with a of This will the of variables on the of commuting to a preschool further we the by in Sweden with at least one and or in Sweden with two This the to avoidance behaviour as well as to an of strategies that be different between these The that are more likely to be to convert social and economic capital into favourable the non-native part of the population have an on the to commute to preschools. of such will in the for the variables in the by which preschool the children attend and the the the of the some of which need further Public preschools are by far the preschool type and for-profit companies as have a large share of preschool children in Stockholm to for co-operatives are run as economic these are for the of their economic interests. There is no in this form of and the parents are the of the In the we find staff co-operatives, preschools driven by and other preschools. In order to or the social of the children's we on of capital and the of social space. This that the of different social groups on their composition and the volume of their and assets, which with different positions from which to and the in relation to other (Bourdieu, 1994). However, to with our we have our analytical of social groups to the of and education, and economic In the Bourdieusian of a between social groups for educational capital is more important for their social position and dispositions in social space, and those for economic capital is more important et al., et al., Bourdieu, Forsberg, et al., 2018). In order to such an we have a of five This especially for the more affluent between families by their educational to their economic and those with less educational We the families' level of education as an of capital, and in as an of economic capital in we for a of by a Bourdieusian social et al., these social background variables both and when how families' commuting patterns to their social In with the white/native avoidance a of variables are in the In this the are These by Sweden and launched in The take into in the such as and the extent of as well as on In Stockholm there are with a population of at this it is that preschool children who attend their closest preschool to a larger attend preschools, and especially parental co-operatives and for-profit preschools. Commuting also more common among with a and among children with there are small differences between and it as attend preschools with children and children There is also a of among the educational of the and among children of parents within the and There to be more commuting among families to social groups with higher of capital, which is in with findings from compulsory school et al., We the by of the different preschool types in Stockholm co-operatives and other co-operatives have children while for-profit preschools have the of children Most common in all when the population by is to attend a public as the large share of such schools. However, both are in parental co-operatives, other co-operatives and for-profit schools. children in Sweden with parents are in the same types of preschools, while there also is a of children in for-profit preschools. The of the in some types of preschools be by choices of where to preschools. As in the most in higher neighbourhoods, while the tends to in the It is that public preschools are for the shares in neighbourhoods. preschools are more common in higher in other with patterns for parental co-operatives. co-operatives, on the other are more common in neighbourhoods. The socio-economic difference in patterns also to be on the of the type of with the of preschools in higher as the most This that there no commuting the closest preschools, more children attend parental co-operatives and for-profit preschools, as these and preschools tend to be in the same neighbourhoods. This is in the case, as in make choices their children will commute, and some commuting is related to where parents are to their children to preschools, as their free some differences in between the closest preschool and the preschool that children Thus, a few and of social of school and social It is that all for the have children at the preschool where are at their closest preschool. of this is that the patterns tend to the at the preschools, to there no free choice and all children the closest preschool. from the economic of the the differences are small when it comes to the of patterns on all groups for the tend to choose preschools with staff the closest preschool. the and the it that some groups from free school while others it be that in with an of private preschool options commute in the same extent more choices in the preschool are in their The the of various background on the that how preschools there are between the and the preschool that the in the indicate an increased of commuting In the a of individual are to the on commuting for preschool children. The findings show that those to the and are less likely to commute distances the of This is that that higher social make more of private school and the in this paper that there is an of these types of preschools in where with socio-economic resources tend to The these in far as it is that the economic tends to be less likely to commute the while other differences are small differences between social groups in this small differences can be when it comes to the of children's and age on commuting. that children who in other or whose parents are more likely to Furthermore, the type of preschool that the commuting. The co-operatives increase the of commuting which may be an of these preschools less The of these and their of when level and preschool in Commuting is less common in with higher shares of high and higher shares of with children. It may also be that commuting is more common in other it comes to the of the closest preschool it that those a co-operative preschool are more inclined to commute those who to other types of preschools. This be to the of co-operative preschools, which some of work from the It may also be an of the small of these preschools. There may be few for all children whose closest preschool is a parental These preschools and the findings indicate that some avoid while others commute to few children in the closest preschool commuting. As in the part of the paper, the to be those who pay the most attention to the composition of preschool higher share of staff at the closest preschool the to commute, even the is In the we the to The results show that the background is to the composition Swedish background in a Swedish the to commute is and These results be a of The avoidance is with the This that the and are more likely to commute in neighbourhoods, to the of in neighbourhoods. It is that socio-economic differences between a and the increase the of in a preschool further and in the background further there is a higher of commuting among the This be a of families' choice to commute – out of an In order to analyse the differences we the by and The by and results as with the there are no differences between social groups within the for the for the in relation to the when for while the a to commute among the of the and However, the is when for For the economic of a of commuting in neighbourhoods, and a higher in neighbourhoods, are among the Swedish background We between background and that children with foreign backgrounds to a higher attend preschools in to their This that has or are to the educational and the differences between the and the is larger within the in The part of the population has had the possibility to choose where to to the same extent as those with a Swedish to the educational This is even more when groups The higher social positions that with the are associated with a to commute for the while it a higher of commuting for the be the of the of commuting. only children and when a with or or and we find results as in the we an with distance to preschool as the The results are to the travel further their children attend parental co-operatives or other co-operatives. The more affluent social groups tend to travel shorter distances. The findings are also for families in where are different from the majority population tend to travel further to In this paper, we what is, to the of our the full population study of preschool children's commuting in a large begin children commuting to preschool in all social groups in the However, all social groups the the at their to their closest preschool. Furthermore, we see that parents within that high volume of capital are more likely to commute with their children to preschools to the co-operatives are the most type of preschool that from the However, these are also by parents a commute, most likely these preschools a level of parental or that are and may be to all the children in their We find some social avoidance behaviour as far as the to commute tends to increase for families in neighbourhoods, and these results are more for the with a We further show of This in our that parents tend to make choices on composition of the preschools closest to and avoid preschools that are in with their differences we see that the groups with is more to commute, while families with to social groups with less economic resources are more in their own to their with We find less from social groups this be by the of preschool locations, especially among the co-operative and for-profit preschools. We how high volume of capital especially in the with we find that the and within the are to the preschool and strategies to social In with the preschools that social groups with are in higher status neighbourhoods, parents with a and a for such preschools to commute to Our capital the to commute and this is especially important for groups that have to convert different forms of capital to more attractive neighbourhoods, in with the we detect but also higher to commute among the with from with a high share of and preschool commuting to be a in that families the when However, a large social in the preschools is which findings from & We out policy from our All social but the their when the preschools that are in with the closest preschool. This how resources more to the geographical distribution of are in for the the differences from at preschools. more to families help make more choices but of resources to preschools with more children be The high of commuting among the more affluent with a be as a This lack economic capital, or the possibility to and have in the The preschool to convert educational capital into social capital type and by commuting their children. In this free preschool choice is the with education and a this possibility which a need for it is in that commuting to preschools even that families are of differences in between preschools, which be the policy and of preschools. This is in with the and that choices of types of preschools and composition of is to preschools preschool as well as We are for research from that this research We to the and for on of this to and for part in the of this research within the at the of and at
28