EngagedScholarship - Cleveland State University Scholarly & Creative Work from CSU (Cleveland State University) · 2012 · 10 citations · 0 references
Open access
LawConstitutional LawPublic LawJudicial PoliticsJudicial ReviewLawmakingJudicial Decision-makingJudicial DeferenceJudicial InstitutionsJudicial PolicymakingPrecedent InterpretationStare DecisisCourt PrecedentDeference In Federal CourtsLevelsPrecedent ReasoningPrecedent-based InterpretationPrecedential Authority
While circuit courts are bound to follow circuit precedent under "law of the circuit" the practice among federal district courts is more varied and uncertain, routinely involving little or no deference to their own precedent.I argue that the different hierarchical levels and institutional characteristics do not account for the differences in practices between circuit and district courts.Rather, district courts can and should adopt a "law of the district" similar to that of circuit courts.Through this narrow proposal, I explore the historical stare decisis practices in federal courts that are not Supreme.