Journal of Medical Virology · 2020 · 114 citations · 10 references
MedicineInfectious DiseasesMolecular BiologyMolecular DiagnosticsMolecular VirologyVirologyDiagnostic Test EvaluationInfectious Disease DetectionInfectious Disease Molecular TestingPathogen DetectionPoint-of-care Molecular TestingViral DiagnosticsComparative Assay EvaluationCoronavirus DiagnosticsDiagnostic Accuracy StudiesDiagnostic Testing AccuracyPcr-based DetectionPolymerase Chain Reaction (Pcr) AssaysPolymerase Chain Reaction (Pcr) DiagnosticsPolymerase Chain Reaction Detection
Abstract There are more than 350 real‐time polymerase chain reaction (RT‐PCR) coronavirus disease‐2019 (COVID‐19) testing kits commercially available but these kits have not been evaluated for pooled sample testing. Thus, this study was planned to compare and evaluate seven commercially available kits for pooled samples testing. Diagnostic accuracy of (1) TRUPCR SARS‐CoV‐2 Kit (Black Bio), (2) TaqPath RT‐PCR COVID‐19 Kit (Thermo Fisher Scientific), (3) Allplex 2019‐nCOV Assay (Seegene), (4) Patho detect COVID‐19 PCR kit (My Lab), (5) LabGun COVID‐19 RT‐PCR Kit (Lab Genomics, Korea), (6) Fosun COVID‐19 RT‐PCR detection kit (Fosun Ltd.), (7) Real‐time Fluorescent RT‐PCR kit for SARS CoV‐2 (BGI) was evaluated on precharacterised 40 positive and 10 negative COVID‐19 sample pools. All seven kits detected all sample pools with low C t values (<30); while testing weak positive pooled samples with high C t value (>30); the TRUPCR Kit, TaqPath Kit, Allplex Assay, and BGI RT‐PCR kit showed 100% sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy. However, the Fosun kit, LabGun Kit, and Patho detect kit could detect only 90%, 85%, and 75% of weakly positive samples, respectively. We conclude that all seven commercially available RT‐PCR kits included in this study can be used for routine molecular diagnosis of COVID‐19. However, regarding performing pooled sample testing, it might be advisable to use those kits that performed best regarding positive identification in samples' pool, that is TRUPCR SARS‐CoV‐2 Kit, TaqPath RT‐PCR COVID‐19 Kit, Allplex 2019‐nCOV Assay, and BGI Real‐time RT‐PCR kit for detecting SARS CoV‐2.
10
A Novel Coronavirus from Patients with Pneumonia in China, 2019
Na Zhu, Dingyu Zhang, Xingwang Li et al. · New England Journal of Medicine · 2020 · 30.4K citations · Full text
Detection of 2019 novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) by real-time RT-PCR
Victor M. Corman, Olfert Landt, Marco Kaiser et al. · Eurosurveillance · 2020 · 8.2K citations · Full text
The Detection of Defective Members of Large Populations
Robert Dorfman · The Annals of Mathematical Statistics · 1943 · 1.7K citations · Full text
Life Sciences, Biology, Genetics +4
Laboratory Diagnosis of COVID-19: Current Issues and Challenges
Yi‐Wei Tang, Jonathan E. Schmitz, David H. Persing et al. · Journal of Clinical Microbiology · 2020 · 1.3K citations · Full text
Evaluation of COVID-19 RT-qPCR Test in Multi sample Pools
Idan Yelin, Noga Aharony, Einat Shaer Tamar et al. · Clinical Infectious Diseases · 2020 · 452 citations · Full text