Journal of Medical Ethics · 2020 · 81 citations · 9 references
The COVID‑19 pandemic has highlighted key ethical challenges for healthcare workers, including isolation, social distancing, duty of care, fair access to treatment, and the needs of the poor and socially disadvantaged. The authors advocate a relational ethical framework centered on solidarity, relational autonomy, duty, equity, trust, and reciprocity. The paper examines relational autonomy, solidarity, reciprocity, utility, equity, and guideline‑based dilemmas around triage, do‑not‑resuscitate, and treatment withdrawal. The authors conclude by calling for broader discussion of relational ethics and envisioning a post‑pandemic future.
Key ethical challenges for healthcare workers arising from the COVID-19 pandemic are identified: isolation and social distancing, duty of care and fair access to treatment. The paper argues for a relational approach to ethics which includes solidarity, relational autonomy, duty, equity, trust and reciprocity as core values. The needs of the poor and socially disadvantaged are highlighted. Relational autonomy and solidarity are explored in relation to isolation and social distancing. Reciprocity is discussed with reference to healthcare workers’ duty of care and its limits. Priority setting and access to treatment raise ethical issues of utility and equity. Difficult ethical dilemmas around triage, do not resuscitate decisions, and withholding and withdrawing treatment are discussed in the light of recently published guidelines. The paper concludes with the hope for a wider discussion of relational ethics and a glimpse of a future after the pandemic has subsided.
9
Development of a triage protocol for critical care during an influenza pandemic
Laura Hawryluck, Randy S. Wax, Tim Cook et al. · Canadian Medical Association Journal · 2006 · 379 citations · Full text
Pandemic influenza preparedness: an ethical framework to guide decision-making
Alison Thompson, Karen Faith, Jennifer Gibson et al. · BMC Medical Ethics · 2006 · 280 citations · Full text
A Relational Account of Public Health Ethics
Nuala Kenny, Susan Sherwin · Public Health Ethics · 2008 · 226 citations
On pandemics and the duty to care: whose duty? who cares?
Carly Ruderman, C. Shawn Tracy, Cécile M. Bensimon et al. · BMC Medical Ethics · 2006 · 203 citations · Full text