Agenda Seeding: How 1960s Black Protests Moved Elites, Public Opinion and Voting

Omar Wasow

American Political Science Review · 2020 · 502 citations · 107 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Elite influence theories suggest marginal groups have little power, yet elites do not hold a monopoly over political communication. The study seeks to explain how stigmatized minorities advance agendas through agenda seeding, hypothesizing that protest tactics shape media framing. The authors introduce agenda seeding, describing how activists use disruption to attract media attention and hypothesize that protest tactics influence news framing. Nonviolent protests, especially when met with repression, amplified media coverage, framing, and public opinion on civil rights and increased Democratic vote share in nearby counties, while violent protests shifted white voters toward Republicans and helped decide the 1968 election.

Abstract

How do stigmatized minorities advance agendas when confronted with hostile majorities? Elite theories of influence posit marginal groups exert little power. I propose the concept of agenda seeding to describe how activists use methods like disruption to capture the attention of media and overcome political asymmetries. Further, I hypothesize protest tactics influence how news organizations frame demands. Evaluating black-led protests between 1960 and 1972, I find nonviolent activism, particularly when met with state or vigilante repression, drove media coverage, framing, congressional speech, and public opinion on civil rights. Counties proximate to nonviolent protests saw presidential Democratic vote share increase 1.6–2.5%. Protester-initiated violence, by contrast, helped move news agendas, frames, elite discourse, and public concern toward “social control.” In 1968, using rainfall as an instrument, I find violent protests likely caused a 1.5–7.9% shift among whites toward Republicans and tipped the election. Elites may dominate political communication but hold no monopoly.

References

107