Uptake and implementation of Nature-Based Solutions: An analysis of barriers using Interpretive Structural Modeling

Shahryar Sarabi, Qi Han, A.G.L. Romme, Bauke de Vries, Rianne Valkenburg, Elke den Ouden

Journal of Environmental Management · 2020 · 205 citations · 48 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Cities face climate change and urbanization challenges, and nature‑based solutions are increasingly viewed as multifunctional approaches, yet their adoption remains limited by various barriers. The study seeks to develop a taxonomy of the dominant barriers to NBS uptake and implementation and map their interrelationships. The authors identified fifteen barriers from literature and expert interviews, ranked them with a questionnaire, then applied Interpretive Structural Modeling to map interdependencies into a six‑level structure, and used MICMAC analysis to classify the barriers into four categories. Political, institutional, and knowledge‑related barriers are the most dominant, and cities can use these insights to prioritize and manage NBS actions more effectively.

Abstract

Cities increasingly have to find innovative ways to address challenges arising from climate change and urbanization. Nature-based solutions (NBS) have been gaining attention as multifunctional solutions that may help cities to address these challenges. However, the adoption and implementation of these solutions have been limited due to various barriers. This study aims to identify a taxonomy of dominant barriers to the uptake and implementation of NBS and their relationships. Fifteen barriers are identified from the literature and expert interviews and then ranked through a questionnaire. Interpretive Structural Modeling (ISM) serves to identify the mutual interdependencies among these barriers, which results in a structural model of six levels. Subsequently, Cross-impact matrix multiplication applied to classification (MICMAC analysis) is used to classify the barriers into four categories. The results suggest that political, institutional and knowledge-related barriers are the most dominant barriers to NBS. Cities that intend to apply NBS can draw on these findings, especially by more effectively prioritizing and managing their actions.

References

48