Social Epistemology · 2020 · 60 citations · 40 references
Social SciencesCommunicationEpistemologyPersuasionScience CommunicationPublic Understanding Of ScienceScientific ConsensusScientific EvidenceScientific KnowledgeSource CredibilityCredibility In Science CommunicationExpert Testimony CommunicationHeuristicsScience DenialismScience SkepticismScientific DisagreementScientific Expert TestimonyScientific Persuasion
There is a large gap between the specialized knowledge of scientists and laypeople’s understanding of the sciences. The novice-expert problem arises when non-experts are confronted with (real or apparent) scientific disagreement, and when they don’t know whom to trust. Because they are not able to gauge the content of expert testimony, they rely on imperfect heuristics to evaluate the trustworthiness of scientists. This paper investigates why some bodies of scientific knowledge become polarized along political fault lines. Laypeople navigate conflicting epistemic and social demands in their acceptance of scientific testimony; this might explain their deference to scientific fringe theories, which often goes together with denying established scientific theories. I evaluate three approaches to mitigate denialism: improving the message, improving the messenger, and improving the environment in which the message is conveyed.
40
Forming impressions of personality.
Journal of Abnormal & Social Psychology · 1946 · 2.5K citations
Virgil Michel · New Scholasticism · 1928 · 2.2K citations
Cultural cognition of scientific consensus
Dan M. Kahan, Hank Jenkins‐Smith, Donald Braman · Journal of Risk Research · 2010 · 1.6K citations
Dan Sperber, Fabrice Clément, Christophe Heintz et al. · Mind & Language · 2010 · 1.6K citations