Journal of Epidemiology · 2020 · 82 citations · 41 references
Public HealthBiostatisticsCausal InferenceEpidemiologic MethodsEpidemiologyCausal Effect EstimationCausal Graphical ModelsDirected Acyclic GraphsMatching MethodsCase-control Association StudiesCausal Effect IdentificationCausal Effects IdentificationCausal EstimationCausal Inference From DataConfounding ControlGraphical Causal ModelsGraphical Models
Graphical models are useful tools in causal inference, and causal directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) are used extensively to determine the variables for which it is sufficient to control for confounding to estimate causal effects. We discuss the following ten pitfalls and tips that are easily overlooked when using DAGs: 1) Each node on DAGs corresponds to a random variable and not its realized values; 2) The presence or absence of arrows in DAGs corresponds to the presence or absence of individual causal effect in the population; 3) "Non-manipulable" variables and their arrows should be drawn with care; 4) It is preferable to draw DAGs for the total population, rather than for the exposed or unexposed groups; 5) DAGs are primarily useful to examine the presence of confounding in distribution in the notion of confounding in expectation; 6) Although DAGs provide qualitative differences of causal structures, they cannot describe details of how to adjust for confounding; 7) DAGs can be used to illustrate the consequences of matching and the appropriate handling of matched variables in cohort and case-control studies; 8) When explicitly accounting for temporal order in DAGs, it is necessary to use separate nodes for each timing; 9) In certain cases, DAGs with signed edges can be used in drawing conclusions about the direction of bias; and 10) DAGs can be (and should be) used to describe not only confounding bias but also other forms of bias. We also discuss recent developments of graphical models and their future directions.
41
Statistics and Causal Inference
Paul W. Holland · Journal of the American Statistical Association · 1986 · 5.1K citations
Causal Diagrams for Epidemiologic Research
Sander Greenland, Judea Pearl, James M. Robins · Epidemiology · 1999 · 3.7K citations
Air Pollution and Hospital Admissions for Heart Disease in Eight U.S. Counties
Epidemiology · 1999 · 3.1K citations
A Structural Approach to Selection Bias
Miguel A. Hernán, Sonia Hernández–Dı́az, James M. Robins · Epidemiology · 2004 · 2.8K citations
Principles of confounder selection
Tyler J. VanderWeele · European Journal of Epidemiology · 2019 · 1.5K citations · Full text