When is Disinformation (In)Credible? Experimental Findings on Message Characteristics and Individual Differences

Leonie Schaewitz, Jan P. Kluck, Lukas Klösters, Nicole C. Krämer

Mass Communication & Society · 2020 · 80 citations · 41 references

Concepts

Abstract

Disinformation on the Internet has become a major threat to our society. Especially false and inaccurate information in the form of news might have detrimental consequences for the democratic process when biasing individuals' political views. To combat disinformation, a necessary first step is to investigate the factors relevant for individuals to detected false information online. Hence, we conducted an experiment (N = 294) to investigate effects of message factors and individual differences on individuals' credibility and accuracy perceptions of disinformation as well as on their likelihood of sharing them. Results suggest that message factors, such as the source, inconsistencies, subjectivity, sensationalism, or manipulated images, seem less important for users' evaluations of disinformation articles than individual differences. While need for cognition seems most relevant for accuracy perceptions, the opinion toward the news topic seems most crucial for whether people believe in the news and share it online.

References

41