Biomechanics Following Isolated Posterolateral Corner Reconstruction Comparing a Fibular‐Based Docking Technique With a Tibia and Fibular–Based Anatomic Technique Show Either Technique is Acceptable

Abstract

PURPOSE: To analyze the biomechanical integrity of 2 posterolateral corner (PLC) reconstruction techniques using a sophisticated robotic biomechanical system that enables analysis of joint kinematics under dynamic external loads. METHODS: Eight cadaveric human knee specimens were tested. Five N·m external torque followed by 5 N·m varus torque was dynamically applied to each specimen. The 6 degrees of freedom kinematics of the joint were measured in 4 states (intact, PLC-deficient, fibular-based docking, and anatomic PLC reconstructed) at 30°, 60°, and 90° of flexion. Tibial external rotation (ER) and varus rotation (VR) were compared. RESULTS: Under external torque, ER significantly increased from the intact state to the PLC-deficient state across all flexion angles. At 30° of flexion, ER was not significantly different between the intact state (19.9°) and fibular-based (18.7°, P = .336) and anatomic reconstructions (14.9°, P = .0977). At 60°, ER was not significantly different between the intact state and fibular-based reconstruction (22.4°, compared with 19.8° in intact; P = .152) but showed overconstraint after anatomic reconstruction (15.7°; P = .0315). At 90°, ER was not significantly different between the intact state and anatomic reconstruction (15.4°, compared with 19.7° in intact; P = .386) but was with the fibular-based technique (23.5°; P = .0125). CONCLUSION: Both a fibular-based docking technique and an anatomic technique for isolated PLC reconstruction provided appropriate constraint through most tested knee range of motion, yet the fibular-based docking technique underconstrained the knee at 90°, and the anatomic reconstruction overconstrained the knee at 60°. Biomechanically, either technique may be considered for surgical treatment of high-grade isolated PLC injuries. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: This biomechanical study utilizing clinically-relevant dynamic forces on the knee shows that either a simplified fibular-based docking technique or a more complex anatomic technique may be considered for surgical treatment of high-grade isolated PLC injuries.