Political Science Quarterly · 2019 · 63 citations · 0 references
Social SciencesPolitical SciencePublic PolicyAmerican PoliticsFiscal PolicyTaxationEconomic RecoveryFiscal HistoryFiscal PoliticsTax ReformFiscal Policy HistoryParty ElitesRedistributive Fiscal PolicyRepublican GovernmentTax Bracket CreepTax CutsTaxation PoliticsWelfare State Redistribution
Why has the Republican Party centered its domestic agenda around tax cuts for three decades? Monica Prasad presents a thorough, complicated, and convincing story of the political motivations and impact of Ronald Reagan’s Economic Recovery Tax Act (ERTA) of 1981. Starving the Beast argues that the ERTA marked the transformation of the Republican Party from a party of fiscal responsibility to one of tax cuts. Reagan showed his fellow Republicans that running on tax cuts was not only electorally popular but came with no economic or political costs. Republicans could now distribute government benefits through the tax code as a counter to Democratic expansions of the welfare state. This strategy united disparate factions within the party and is still one of the GOP’s only popular policy positions. Prasad argues that the political and economic environment of the late 1970s provides the context for the success of the ERTA. The Republican Party’s reputation was in ruins after Watergate, and party elites were desperate for a winning electoral message that could challenge Democratic congressional control. A period of high inflation resulted in bracket creep, moving households into higher tax ranges and eroding consumer purchasing power. Reagan’s response to voter concerns about the economy was the ERTA, which focused on cutting individual marginal rates for three consecutive years. President Reagan championed the ERTA as a rationale for the economic recovery leading up to the 1984 election, while Democrat Walter Mondale promised to raise taxes. Reagan won in a landslide and, although not causal, the link was established between promising lower taxes and Republican electoral success. Every Republican presidential nominee since has made tax cuts a central part of their campaign platform.