Health Affairs · 2019 · 234 citations · 5 references
Social SciencesHealth PolicyHuman GeographyHealth EquityRural DevelopmentRural HealthRural Community DevelopmentRural Development PolicyRural GovernanceRural Health EquityRural Health PolicyRural Service ProvisionMeasurement Bias CorrectionResearch Outcomes AssessmentRural EquityRural Health InequalitiesRural Health Services DevelopmentRural Population HealthRural Public Health PracticeRural Resource Access
Rural health monitoring is hampered by inconsistent definitions of rural, causing confusion and inequitable resource allocation across federal, state, and local agencies. The article examines how inconsistent rural definitions bias research measurements, outcomes interpretation, and grant eligibility. The authors propose new concepts to refine and frame rurality definitions. The paper recommends tailored definitions and usage guidelines to better serve rural residents.
Monitoring and improving rural health is challenging because of varied and conflicting concepts of just what rural means. Federal, state, and local agencies and data resources use different definitions, which may lead to confusion and inequity in the distribution of resources depending on the definition used. This article highlights how inconsistent definitions of rural may lead to measurement bias in research, the interpretation of research outcomes, and differential eligibility for rural-focused grants and other funding. We conclude by making specific recommendations on how policy makers and researchers could use these definitions more appropriately, along with definitions we propose, to better serve rural residents. We also describe concepts that may improve the definition of and frame the concept of rurality.
5