“Tense” and “lax” in four minority languages of China

Ian Maddieson, Peter Ladefoged

Journal of Phonetics · 1985 · 94 citations · 23 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

The terms “tense” and “lax” have been applied to vowel distinctions in many languages, and in Southeast Asian studies they are used to describe phonological contrasts whose primary component is phonation type. The authors collected aerodynamic and acoustic data on four southwestern Chinese languages—Jingpho, Hani, Yi, and Wa—to investigate these distinctions. Vowel quality, duration, and adjacent consonants were inconsistently involved, but measurements showed that lax vowels have higher oral airflow relative to subglottal pressure and a larger fundamental-to-second-harmonic amplitude ratio, confirming the contrast is phonation type and prompting a discussion of its historical significance and a proposed alternative terminology.

Abstract

The terms “tense” and “lax” have been applied to a number of different distinctions between vowel sets depending on the language(s) being discussed. Linguists working on south-east Asian languages have used these terms to discuss phonological contrasts whose main component we can show to be one of phonation type. Aerodynamic and acoustic data were collected on four languages spoken in south-western China—Jingpho, Hani, Yi and Wa. Vowel quality and duration and some properties of adjacent consonants were involved in the distinction in some of these languages, but not in a consistent way. However, oral airflow is greater for “lax” vowels, particularly when considered in relation to the subglottal pressure (inferred from measurements of the oral pressure in voiceless bilabial stops preceding the vowel). Also the fundamental has greater amplitude relative to the second harmonic in “lax” vowels than in “tense” vowels. The agreement between these two measures confirms that the contrast is one of the phonation type. The historical and descriptive significance of the results is discussed, and an alternative to the tense/lax terminology proposed.

References

23