Anthropology Today · 2019 · 14 citations · 8 references
MedicinePsychiatryMental Health CareMental Health PromotionTrauma-related DisordersTrauma DisordersTrauma NarrativesTrauma-focused PsychotherapySocial ImpactSocioeconomic BenefitsTrauma In Post-conflict SettingsTrauma Narrative WorkWar Trauma Narratives
A well‐known medical journal, The Lancet , recently published an important systematic review and meta‐analysis of mental disorder estimates in conflict settings, advocating for the scaling up of mental health interventions in such contexts. However, there is an assumption that the introduction of such treatments has no significant impact, except from a therapeutic one, in the settings they have been imported to. The authors' research in post‐conflict northern Uganda analyzed the social impact of mental health interventions addressing post‐traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and showed that promoting trauma has had considerable socio‐economic ramifications on the wider society. The introduction of trauma narratives has created a market where some are able to thrive, but many deeply troubled individuals remain invisible. The authors found no social benefits from promoting trauma, and few positive effects for individuals. Arguments for urgently upscaling mental health interventions of the kinds highlighted by the review in The Lancet , and which the authors have observed on the ground, should be treated with caution.
8
Civil War, Reintegration, and Gender in Northern Uganda
Jeannie Annan, Christopher Blattman, Dyan Mazurana et al. · Journal of Conflict Resolution · 2011 · 276 citations
Afterword: Against “global mental health”
Derek Summerfield · Transcultural Psychiatry · 2012 · 237 citations
Vanessa Pupavac · European Journal of Social Theory · 2004 · 88 citations · Full text
Social Sciences, International Relations, Political Science +11