Berichte zur Wissenschaftsgeschichte · 2019 · 13 citations · 28 references
HumanitiesHistoryMedical EducationHistoriographyIntellectual HistoryNature Of ScienceDemarcation Of ScienceDemarcation ProblemHistorical Development Of ScienceHistory Of ScienceMedical HistoryMedical PluralismHistory Of Medical EducationHistory Of Scientific ConceptsHistory Of Scientific Knowledge
The scope and mission of the history of science have been constant objects of reflection and debate within the profession. Recently, Lorraine Daston has called for a shift of focus: from the history of science to the history of knowledge. Such a move is an attempt at broadening the field and ridding it of the contradictions deriving from its modernist myth of origin and principle of demarcation. Taking the move from a pluralistic concept of medicine, the present paper explores the actual and possible contributions that a history of knowledge can offer to the history of medicine in particular. As we will argue, the history of medicine has always been a history of knowledge, but for good reasons has always stuck to the concept of medicine as its object and problem throughout the ages, including the modern, scientific one. We argue that, in the history of medicine, the demarcation between scientific and non-scientific represents an accident, but is not foundational as in the case of natural science. Furthermore, the history of medicine programmatically played a role in at least two academic domains (history proper and medical education), adjusting historical narratives of medical knowledge to its audience. Accordingly, we underscore that the history of both science and medicine, as traditionally defined, already provides room for almost the whole spectrum of approaches to history. Moreover, their different myths of origin can, and indeed must, be included in the reflexivity of the historical gaze. We argue that the position towards a history of science, medicine, or knowledge is not a question of narrative or theory, rather, it is a question of relevance and awareness of extant contexts.
28
<i>The Structure of Scientific Revolutions</i>
Thomas Kühn, Richard Schlegel · Physics Today · 1963 · 35.5K citations
Humanities, History, Physics +17
Genesis and Development of a Scientific Fact.
Andy Pickering, Ludwik Fleck, Thaddeus J. Trenn et al. · Contemporary Sociology A Journal of Reviews · 1982 · 1.8K citations
Humanities, History, Philosophy +17
Roy Porter · Theory and Society · 1985 · 461 citations
Ways of knowing: a new history of science, technology and medicine
Choice Reviews Online · 2001 · 436 citations
Humanities, History, Philosophy +17
Thomas Kuhn: A Philosophical History for Our Times
Andrew Carpenter, Steve Fuller · The Antioch Review · 2001 · 342 citations
Humanities, History, Philosophy +9