Supramolecular Assistance to Regioselectivity in the Reactions of Chlorocyclophosphazenes with Sodium Oxyanions:  Macrocyclic Effect and Anion Dependence

Abstract

Comparative studies of the naphtholysis of crown-bearing tetrachlorocyclotriphosphazene 2 and its acyclic analogue, nongem-diethoxytetrachlorocyclotriphosphazene 5 (which was synthesized and isolated in the pure cis form for the purpose of this study), reveal a significant macrocyclic effect of the substituent on both the kinetics and regiochemistry of chlorine substitution in the N(3)P(3) ring. Whereas substitution of 5 with sodium naphthoxide provided moderate yields of the respective sterically and electronically favored nongem-naphthoxydiethoxy derivative as the major product, isolated as the mixture of cis and trans isomers 8 + 9, the corresponding reaction of crown substrate 2 resulted in highly regioselective formation of the gem-to-macrocycle substituted mononaphthoxy PNP-crown derivative 11a. The importance of the PNP-crown related effects for the regio- and stereocontrol of the substitution of chlorine atoms in the N(3)P(3) ring is discussed in terms of supramolecular sodium cation-assisted interactions between the ring oxy substituent(s) and incoming oxyanions. To approach the problem of the anion-dependence of the regioselectivity, a comparison has been drawn between the reactions of the PNP-crown substrate 2 with sodium arylates derived from beta-naphthol (10a) and phenol (10b), carried out with equimolar or 100% excess sodium oxyanion with respect to 2, and the corresponding reactions of 2 with sodium monoenolates derived from the beta-dicarbonyl compounds: acetylacetone (10c) and ethyl acetylacetate (10d). The effectiveness of supramolecularly assisted transition state stabilization is found to be dependent not only on the dimensional complementarity between the cation and the macrocycle but also on the properties of the four interacting ionic centers according to the HSAB principle and on the nature of the electronic interaction of the PNP-crown substituent with the N(3)P(3) ring, the latter determining the extent of regiocontrol to either one or two macrocyclic chloride functions. The increase of the extent of regioselectivity of gem-substitution at the PNP-macrocycle when passing from arylate to beta-dicarbonyl enolate oxy anions is related to the observed trends in the (31)P NMR chemical shifts and refers to the electronic structure of the oxy substituent.