The Research Repository @ WVU (West Virginia University) · 1990 · 16 citations · 0 references
Open access
LawConstitutional LawJurisprudenceEqual ProtectionFreedom Of ExpressionNuisanceAbatement Of NuisanceInjunctions In NuisanceIntentional NuisancePublic NuisanceDefense Against NuisanceNuisance CrimeNuisance In FactNuisance StatutesPublic Nuisance Doctrine
To avoid the limitations and burdens of the Assize of Nuisance and the writ quod permittat, litigants sought to redress interferences with land under the newly-developing "action on the case."In the sixteenth century an action on the case for nuisance could be brought when the Assize was not available and there was no other legal remedy. 21By the beginning of the seventeenth century litigants were permitted to elect between the two writs. 22Trespass on the case thereafter "became the usual and established remedy for nuisance.' '2The action on the case for nuisance had one significant disadvantage.Whereas abatement was available under the Assize of Nuisance, the sole remedy in an action on the case was money damages. 24 Abatement was available from the courts of equity, however, which developed equitable principles for nuisance cases that differed from those employed in the common law courts.The separate development of nuisance law in the common law and equity courts was a "potent cause of confusion," especially because the equity courts often did not closely observe the technical labels and distinctions employed by the law courts. 25 Further complexity was introduced as the action on the case for nuisance was broadened to include actions for interference with a public right, such as obstruction of a public highway, by plaintiffs the origins of this writ.