Comparison of environmental assessment methodology in hybrid energy system simulation software

Hemant Sharma, Élise Monnier, Guillaume Mandil, Peggy Zwolinski, Stéphane Colasson

Procedia CIRP · 2019 · 31 citations · 20 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

The advent of renewable energy systems has led to an increase in decentralised energy systems. Consequently, the last 10 years have seen development of specialised software such as HOMER, iHOGA, EnergyPro, RETScreen and TRNSYS to analyse these systems. This study compares these software in detail especially in terms of the environmental assessment. It is concluded that these software do not adequately include environmental analysis since only 1 out of 5 software considers more than one life cycle stage, neglecting other upstream/downstream emissions. Furthermore, the emphasis is on emissions such as NOx and SO2 that are usually associated with fossil fuel utilization. As the energy systems are becoming increasingly complex, especially with storage technologies such as hydrogen and batteries, emissions ‘shift’ away from the operating stage. Moreover, it becomes essential to look further than global warming potential and take into account other impacts such as depletion of critical materials, acidification, eco-toxicity, etc. Hence, it becomes essential to take into account entire life cycle stages and provide comprehensive environmental impacts along with the already available techno-economic capabilities to the designers and decision-makers. Finally, this study provides recommendations on the methodology to include environmental analysis in the investigated software.

References

20