The Accounting Review · 2019 · 86 citations · 34 references
LawCorporate LawCorporate DisclosureCorporate LitigationCorporate ReportingDisclosureSecurities LitigationShareholder LitigationDisclosure LitigationLegal Liability RiskLitigation Risk ManagementSafe Harbor LawsSafe Harbor LiabilitySafe Harbor ProtectionsShareholder Litigation DefenseShielding
ABSTRACT Prior research finds that positive tone in firms' qualitative disclosures increases the risk of shareholder lawsuits. However, federal securities laws provide a safe harbor intended to shield firms' forward-looking statements from legal liability. One implication of this safe harbor is that litigation risk potentially varies between qualitative forward- and non-forward-looking statements. Consistent with this implication, we find that positive tone in forward-looking qualitative statements is significantly less related to the likelihood of subsequent litigation than is positive tone in non-forward-looking qualitative statements. On average, we fail to find a significant association between qualitative forward-looking statements and subsequent litigation. We do find evidence, however, that positive tone in qualitative forward-looking statements relates positively to subsequent litigation in two U.S. circuits in which court rulings reduced safe harbor protections for forward-looking statements. Overall, our results are consistent with the safe harbor effectively shielding firms' qualitative forward-looking statements from litigation risk.
34
Why Firms Voluntarily Disclose Bad News
Douglas J. Skinner · Journal of Accounting Research · 1994 · 2.6K citations
Business, Accountancy, Accounting +17
Textual Analysis in Accounting and Finance: A Survey
Tim Loughran, Bill McDonald · Journal of Accounting Research · 2016 · 2.2K citations