Vertex Corrections to the Polarizability Do Not Improve the <i>GW</i> Approximation for the Ionization Potential of Molecules

Abstract

The GW approximation is based on the neglect of vertex corrections, which appear in the exact self-energy and the exact polarizability. Here, we investigate the importance of vertex corrections in the polarizability only. We calculate the polarizability with equation-of-motion coupled-cluster theory with single and double excitations (EOM-CCSD), which rigorously includes a large class of diagrammatically defined vertex corrections beyond the random phase approximation (RPA). As is well-known, the frequency-dependent polarizability predicted by EOM-CCSD is quite different and generally more accurate than that predicted by the RPA. We evaluate the effect of these vertex corrections on a test set of 20 atoms and molecules. When using a Hartree-Fock reference, ionization potentials predicted by the GW approximation with the RPA polarizability are typically overestimated with a mean absolute error of 0.3 eV. However, those predicted with a vertex-corrected polarizability are typically underestimated with an increased mean absolute error of 0.5 eV. This result suggests that vertex corrections in the self-energy cannot be neglected, at least for molecules. We also assess the behavior of eigenvalue self-consistency in vertex-corrected GW calculations, finding a further worsening of the predicted ionization potentials.