Moral Crumple Zones: Cautionary Tales in Human-Robot Interaction

Madeleine Clare Elish

Engaging Science Technology and Society · 2019 · 238 citations · 24 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

Debates over AI policy and ethics increasingly focus on assigning responsibility in distributed, time‑mediated systems, and the concept of a moral crumple zone—analogous to a car’s crumple zone—highlights how humans can become unjustly burdened with moral and legal duties when automated systems fail. The study introduces the moral crumple zone concept by analyzing high‑profile accidents in complex automated systems and their media coverage to show how responsibility can be misattributed to human actors with limited control. The author examines several high‑profile accidents involving complex socio‑technical systems and reviews associated media coverage to develop the moral crumple zone framework.

Abstract

As debates about the policy and ethical implications of AI systems grow, it will be increasingly important to accurately locate who is responsible when agency is distributed in a system and control over an action is mediated through time and space. Analyzing several high-profile accidents involving complex and automated socio-technical systems and the media coverage that surrounded them, I introduce the concept of a moral crumple zone to describe how responsibility for an action may be misattributed to a human actor who had limited control over the behavior of an automated or autonomous system. Just as the crumple zone in a car is designed to absorb the force of impact in a crash, the human in a highly complex and automated system may become simply a component—accidentally or intentionally—that bears the brunt of the moral and legal responsibilities when the overall system malfunctions. While the crumple zone in a car is meant to protect the human driver, the moral crumple zone protects the integrity of the technological system, at the expense of the nearest human operator. The concept is both a challenge to and an opportunity for the design and regulation of human-robot systems. At stake in articulating moral crumple zones is not only the misattribution of responsibility but also the ways in which new forms of consumer and worker harm may develop in new complex, automated, or purported autonomous technologies.

References

24