International Data Privacy Law · 2019 · 13 citations · 0 references
LawAdministrative LawHuman Rights LawHuman RightsIntellectual PropertyJurisdictionData ProtectionDigital RightsEuropean LawPrivacy LawRight To PrivacySuppression Of EvidenceData ProcessingEuropean Union TreatiesPersonal DataPersonal Data HandlingPersonal Data ProcessingRight Of PrivacyRight To Be ForgottenTerritorial Scope Of Protection
The ‘right to be forgotten’ (RTBF),1 or more precisely the ‘right to suppression’2 continues its judicial saga as it is being examined by the very same Court that created it, following the submission of 11 preliminary questions3 by the French Council of State before the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU).4 Created by the CJEU in its Google Spain judgment on 13 May 2014,5 the right to be deindexed has been seen as ‘triply audacious’6 with regard to its legal implications. First, it includes in the territorial scope of Directive 95/467 the search engine activity performed by Google Inc. from the USA. To this end, the Court first established that, although it had only a technical role in the processing of the search engine’s data, Google Inc.’s Spanish subsidiary had a business of selling advertising spaces intended for the Spanish market in order to make the service offered by Google Inc. profitable. The Court inferred from this that the personal data processing implemented by Google Inc. was ‘carried out in the context of the activities’8 of its Spanish establishment9 and, hence, that European regulations applied. This is undeniably quite a striking decision, the potential extraterritorial legal effects of which were not demarcated by the Court.10 Such legal effects have been the subject of lively discussions, and even controversies, which this article intends to go over in detail.