5D BIM: an investigation into the integration of quantity surveyors within the BIM process

Mohammad Mayouf, Michael Gerges, Sharon Cox

Journal of Engineering Design and Technology · 2019 · 62 citations · 18 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The study highlights the need to understand stakeholder integration and information requirements for improved technology implementation in BIM. The paper investigates integrating a quantity surveyor role into BIM to facilitate 5D BIM, proposing a level‑of‑development/level‑of‑detail framework and calling for future testing of this approach. The authors conducted 20 semi‑structured interviews with ten academic and ten industry QSs in the UK to explore BIM perspectives, protocols, expectations, and challenges for 5D BIM implementation. The study finds that limited 3D model information undermines 5D BIM reliability for QSs, highlighting the need for workflow and information understanding, while noting complexities and shortfalls that may limit generalizability.

Abstract

Purpose This paper aims to investigate the integration of a quantity surveyor (QS) role and practice within the building information modelling (BIM) process to enable better implementation of five-dimensional building information modelling (5D BIM) (D is a result of the data/information dimension integrated in a BIM model). It proposes the use of a “level of development and level of detail” to provide a structured approach for QSs’ integration within the BIM process for an improved implementation of 5D BIM. Design/methodology/approach This paper uses semi-structured interviews with QSs from academic and industry in the UK. A total of 20 face-to-face semi-structured interviews were conducted with two groups (industrial and academic) of ten participants from the West Midlands region in the UK. The interview questions have focussed on gaining perspectives on BIM, BIM and government protocols for the QS profession, expectations and challenges when implementing 5D BIM. Findings The findings show that BIM is perceived differently, and limitation of information obtained from the 3D models in BIM reduce the reliability of 5D BIM for QSs and implementing of 5D BIM needs an understanding of BIM workflow and information requirements. Research limitations/implications Although the findings reveal many of the complexities that face QSs within the BIM process and the shortfalls of 5D BIM technology, the results may lack generalisation. Thus, future research seeks to test the proposed framework further. Practical implications This paper elicits implications of shortfalls that impact the implementation of 5D BIM technology and the complexities that face QSs within the BIM process. Originality/value This paper reveals the need to understand the process of integrating stakeholders and their information requirements for better implementation of technologies within BIM.

References

18