Antifundamentalism in Modern America

Scott Appleby

Journal of American History · 2018 · 10 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

David Harrington Watt, a professor of history at Temple University, sallies forth to tilt at the windmill known as “global fundamentalisms.” The behemoth in need of slaying, he argues, is the company of Western scholars who agreed to explore and refine the proposition that a daunting array of movements and organizations that emerged fully in the latter half of the twentieth century from within Islam, Christianity, and Judaism—and, surprisingly, from within South Asian Buddhist, Sikh, and Hindu traditions—share certain ideological and organizational traits bound together by a distinctive logic that sets these “fundamentalist” subcultures apart from other modes of late modern religiosity (e.g., liberalism, conservatism, “orthodoxy”). Despite the differences in their respective histories, cosmologies, and practices, these disparate movements are said to manifest a set of “family resemblances.” In brief: they tend to react “militantly” (and sometimes violently) to the post-Enlightenment marginalization of religion. They proceed by selecting and recontextualizing ideologically useful doctrines and practices, such as the apocalyptic advent or return of an avenging Messiah or Hidden Imam. The fundamentalists forge from these repurposed vestiges of a once-enchanted world view the weapons needed to wage a “battle royal” to beat back the forces of atheistic secularism. Ironically, however, these movements also borrow so energetically and indiscriminately from modern technologies, political configurations (e.g., fascism) and habits of mind, that they end up being readily co-opted by mundane nationalist or ethnic extremists.