Text Mining Methods for Social Representation Analysis in Large Corpora

Jean-François Chartier, Jean-Guy Meunier

Papers on Social Representations · 2011 · 61 citations · 0 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Mass digitization has produced vast textual data, and while statistical text mining is increasingly used in social sciences, its application to social representation remains limited because of unclear methodological assumptions and a tendency to conflate software with method. This study aims to demystify the software black box by providing an overview and formalization of a statistical text mining method for social representation, illustrated with Lahlou’s work. The authors explicitly state the linguistic and methodological assumptions and highlight alternative algorithmic operationalizations of the method.

Abstract

With mass text digitization (digital libraries, web, etc.), a huge amount of empirical data is now available for scientific inquiry. In social sciences and humanities, the use of statistical text mining methods to analyze these data has become unavoidable. Saadi Lahlou proposed in the mid-90s a coherent framework for the application of these methods to the study of social representation in large corpora. However, despite this initiative, text mining methods have remained marginal in this research program, partly due to a poor understanding of its methodological and theoretical assumptions. There are still many analyses which confound the software with the method. This paper presents an overview and a formalization of a statistical text mining method for the study of social representation, using Lahlou’s works as illustrations. The goal is to look into the software black box while analyzing the steps and the formal operations involved. The linguistic and methodological assumptions are made explicit and alternative algorithmic operationalizations are highlighted.