Vulgar Latin as an emergent concept in the Italian Renaissance (1435–1601): its ancient and medieval prehistory and its emergence and development in Renaissance linguistic thought

Josef Eskhult

Journal of Latin Linguistics · 2018 · 36 citations · 3 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

The article investigates how the concept of Vulgar Latin emerged as a metalinguistic category during the Italian Renaissance, a topic that has been inconsistently addressed in modern historiography and lacks a unified historical analysis. The paper aims to trace and clarify the prehistory of the Vulgar Latin concept in ancient and medieval linguistic thought. The study analyzes primary sources from antiquity and the Renaissance, surveying the intellectual contexts of debates that shaped the concept. The research finds that before the Renaissance there was no notion of Vulgar Latin as a low‑social variety; the Latin Renaissance revived and modified the term *sermo vulgaris*; the vernacular Italian Renaissance produced a diglossic concept; and these insights revise contemporary historiography.

Abstract

Abstract This article explores the formation of Vulgar Latin as a metalinguistic concept in the Italian Renaissance (1435–1601) considering its continued, although criticized, use as a concept and term in modern Romance and Latin linguistics (1826 until the present). The choice of this topic is justified in view of the divergent previous modern historiography and because of the lack of a coherent historical investigation. The present study is based on a broad selection of primary sources, in particular from classical antiquity and the Italian Renaissance. Firstly, this article traces and clarifies the prehistory of the concept of Vulgar Latin in ancient and medieval linguistic thought. Section 2 demonstrates that the concept of Vulgar Latin as a low social variety does not exist in pre-Renaissance linguistic thought. Secondly, this article describes and analyzes how, why and when the concept of Vulgar Latin emerged and developed in the linguistic thought of the Italian Renaissance. Section 3 surveys the historical intellectual contexts of the debates in which this concept was formed, namely questione della lingua in the Latin and Vernacular Italian Renaissances. Section 4 demonstrates how the ancient concept and term of sermo vulgaris as a diaphasic variety was revived, but also modified, in the Latin Renaissance of the fifteenth century, when the leading humanists developed new ideas on the history, nature and variability of ancient Latin. Section 5 demonstrates how a diglossic concept of Vulgar Latin was formed in the vernacular Italian Renaissance of the sixteenth century, when Italian philologists more carefully approached the topic of the historical origin and emergence of Italian. Thirdly, Section 6 presents a synthesis of the historiographical results that are attained and revises modern historiography on some important points.

References

3