Securing a Long-term Future for Coral Reefs

Ove Hoegh‐Guldberg, Emma Kennedy, Hawthorne L. Beyer, Caleb McClennen, Hugh P. Possingham

Trends in Ecology & Evolution · 2018 · 237 citations · 26 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Severe degradation of coral reefs in recent decades has been driven by a range of threatening processes including climate change. Ocean warming is expected to have further severe impacts on reefs unless global warming is restrained well below 2°C (the goals of the Paris Agreement). Not all coral reefs are equally at risk from climate change, however, suggesting the potential for identifying reefs for conservation action that are less vulnerable to climate change and which may be best positioned for regenerating other degraded reefs in the future. There is uncertainty in future conditions. Variance reduction methods from finance (e.g., modern portfolio theory) can be applied to conservation planning to identify a portfolio of coral reefs for which the risk of widespread failure across the portfolio is minimised. Long-term, risk-sensitive planning in the context of the uncertainty of projected climate impacts complements existing conservation strategies. Rapid ocean warming as a result of climate change poses a key risk for coral reefs. Even if the goals of the Paris Climate Agreement are achieved, coral reefs are likely to decline by 70–90% relative to their current abundance by midcentury. Although alarming, coral communities that survive will play a key role in the regeneration of reefs by mid-to-late century. Here, we argue for a coordinated, global coral reef conservation strategy that is centred on 50 large (500 km2) regions that are the least vulnerable to climate change and which are positioned to facilitate future coral reef regeneration. The proposed strategy and actions should strengthen and expand existing conservation efforts for coral reefs as we face the long-term consequences of intensifying climate change. Rapid ocean warming as a result of climate change poses a key risk for coral reefs. Even if the goals of the Paris Climate Agreement are achieved, coral reefs are likely to decline by 70–90% relative to their current abundance by midcentury. Although alarming, coral communities that survive will play a key role in the regeneration of reefs by mid-to-late century. Here, we argue for a coordinated, global coral reef conservation strategy that is centred on 50 large (500 km2) regions that are the least vulnerable to climate change and which are positioned to facilitate future coral reef regeneration. The proposed strategy and actions should strengthen and expand existing conservation efforts for coral reefs as we face the long-term consequences of intensifying climate change. Coral reefs provide habitat to over a million species as well as essential ecosystem services (e.g., food, coastal protection) to hundreds of millions of people throughout the tropics and subtropics [1Cinner J.E. et al.Vulnerability of coastal communities to key impacts of climate change on coral reef fisheries.Glob. Environ. Change. 2012; 22: 12-20Crossref Scopus (304) Google Scholar, 2Pendleton L. et al.Coral reefs and people in a high-CO2 world: Where can science make a difference to people?.PLoS One. 2016; 11: 1-21Crossref Scopus (52) Google Scholar]. Despite their importance, coral reefs are in rapid decline, with the rate accelerating for many coral reefs over the past decade (e.g., Great Barrier Reef, [3Hughes T.P. et al.Global warming and recurrent mass bleaching of corals.Nature. 2017; 543: 373-377Crossref PubMed Scopus (1687) Google Scholar]). Human impacts such as fishing pressure, coastal development, and pollution are combining with rising ocean temperatures to push reefs increasingly into states typified by low coral abundance, reduced biodiversity, and degraded ecosystems services [1Cinner J.E. et al.Vulnerability of coastal communities to key impacts of climate change on coral reef fisheries.Glob. Environ. Change. 2012; 22: 12-20Crossref Scopus (304) Google Scholar, 2Pendleton L. et al.Coral reefs and people in a high-CO2 world: Where can science make a difference to people?.PLoS One. 2016; 11: 1-21Crossref Scopus (52) Google Scholar]. While all threats facing coral reefs need addressing, those associated with global ocean warming are the most serious, with the near total loss of coral reefs across the planet expected by midcentury under current greenhouse gas emission projections [3Hughes T.P. et al.Global warming and recurrent mass bleaching of corals.Nature. 2017; 543: 373-377Crossref PubMed Scopus (1687) Google Scholar, 4Hoegh-Guldberg O. et al.The ocean.in: Press C.U. Climate Change 2014: Impacts, Adaptation, and Vulnerability. Part B: Regional Aspects. Contribution of Working Group II to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, 2014: 1655-1731Google Scholar, 5Hoegh-Guldberg O. Climate change, coral bleaching and the future of the world’s coral reefs.Mar. Freshw. Res. 1999; 50: 839Crossref Scopus (2623) Google Scholar]. Within this context, reducing the impact of local threats has the potential to build much needed resilience for coral reefs as they face escalating threats from global climate change. The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) and its 21st Conference of the Parties (COP21) agreed to hold ‘the increase in the global average temperature to well below 2°C above preindustrial levels and pursuing efforts to limit the temperature increase to 1.5°C above preindustrial levels’ [6UNFCCC Conference of the Parties (COP) (2015) Paris Climate Change Conference-November 2015, COP 21, 21932Google Scholar]. To date, 180 of the 197 parties have ratified the Paris Agreement on climate change. This agreement is founded upon a scientifically based target under which relatively stable ocean conditions may be achieved by midcentury [4Hoegh-Guldberg O. et al.The ocean.in: Press C.U. Climate Change 2014: Impacts, Adaptation, and Vulnerability. Part B: Regional Aspects. Contribution of Working Group II to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, 2014: 1655-1731Google Scholar]. While current pledges to reduce emissions by the world’s nations fall short of what is required to achieve the goals of the Paris Agreement [7Rogelj J. et al.Paris agreement climate proposals need a boost to keep warming well below 2°C.Nature. 2016; 534: 631-639Crossref PubMed Scopus (1787) Google Scholar], there is considerable hope that the international community will continue to work together to ramp up the emission reduction ambitions of its member states over the coming years. While the Paris Agreement was an impressive political achievement, average planetary surface temperature is expected to increase by another 0.5°C, putting further strain on already stressed natural and human systems. Under optimistic projections, the trend of increasing heat stress may render approximately 70–90% of the current distribution of coral reef habitat unsuitable for most corals [8Frieler K. et al.Limiting global warming to 2°C is unlikely to save most coral reefs.Nat. Clim. Change. 2013; 3: 165-170Crossref Scopus (288) Google Scholar, 9Donner S. et al.Global assessment of coral bleaching and required rates of adaptation under climate change.Glob. Change Biol. 2005; 11: 2251-2265Crossref Scopus (461) Google Scholar, 10Donner S.D. Coping with commitment: projected thermal stress on coral reefs under different future scenarios.PLoS One. 2009; 4e5712Crossref PubMed Scopus (162) Google Scholar]. Failure to achieve the Paris Agreement, however, will see the near total loss of coral reefs for the foreseeable future [4Hoegh-Guldberg O. et al.The ocean.in: Press C.U. Climate Change 2014: Impacts, Adaptation, and Vulnerability. Part B: Regional Aspects. Contribution of Working Group II to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, 2014: 1655-1731Google Scholar]. Pressures from global climate change add to the pressures from local factors such as coastal development, pollution, and overfishing to seriously threaten the viability of coral reefs. Here, we argue for a global, long-term strategy for protecting coral reefs that are both least vulnerable to climate change, and which are well positioned to facilitate the regeneration of many coral reefs later this century (Box 1 and Figure 1). Recognizing that the restoration of coral reefs may make sense at some scales of intervention [11Darling E.S. Côté I.M. Seeking resilience in marine ecosystems.Science. 2018; 359: 986-987Crossref PubMed Scopus (50) Google Scholar, 12Haisfield K.M. et al.An ounce of prevention: cost-effectiveness of coral reef rehabilitation relative to enforcement.Conserv. Lett. 2010; 3: 243-250Crossref Scopus (22) Google Scholar, 13Bayraktarov E. et al.The cost and feasibility of marine coastal restoration.Ecol. Appl. 2016; 26: 1055-1074Crossref PubMed Google Scholar], we argue that the future for coral reefs depends mainly on the success of these approaches being used together with large scale conservation initiatives (Box 2). To ensure that coral reefs persist beyond midcentury, strengthened conservation policies [14Hughes T.P. et al.Rising to the challenge of sustaining coral reef resilience.Trends Ecol. Evol. 2010; 25: 633-642Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (741) Google Scholar], innovative and expanded financing [15Anthony K. et al.New interventions are needed to save coral reefs.Nat. Ecol. Evol. 2017; 1: 1420-1422Crossref PubMed Scopus (138) Google Scholar, 16UN Environment (2018) Analysis of International Funding for the Sustainable Management of Coral Reefs and Associated Coastal Ecosystems. Coral Reef Initiative, UN Environment World Conservation Monitoring Centre. wcmc.io/coralbrochureGoogle Scholar], and increased on-the-ground capacity will all be required [17Page G.G. A Synthesis of Issues Affecting the Management of Coral Reefs and Recommendations for Long-Term Capacity Building in U.S. Jurisdictions. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s Coral Reef Conservation Program, 2015Google Scholar].Box 1Using MPT to Inform ConservationMPT [15Anthony K. et al.New interventions are needed to save coral reefs.Nat. Ecol. Evol. 2017; 1: 1420-1422Crossref PubMed Scopus (138) Google Scholar] is a mathematical approach for building portfolios of assets that maximise the expected return for a given level of risk. The idea is built around the concept that the risk to an asset should be assessed in the context of the overall risk and return of all assets in a given portfolio. Variance-reduction methods are widely used in the financial sector, and MPT was part of the work for which Harry Markowitz received the 1990 Alfred Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences.Conservation planning is also fundamentally concerned with investing limited resources to achieve conservation outcomes (returns) while minimising the risk of failure of those projects. In the case of coral reef conservation, uncertainty in projected long-term conservation outcomes is driven by variation in estimates of climate change impacts. MPT provides a risk-sensitive framework for conservation planning that for the in expected outcomes planning et et planning for coral reef conservation under rapid climate Lett. 2018; Scopus Google Scholar] applied MPT to the of 50 coral reef at a global scale that are the least vulnerable to climate change and which have the potential to also regeneration in other There are impacts of climate on that are to with a of et used to past and projected ocean warming impacts and of as well as to other that the is across a range of of climate change to reduce risk in the while relatively of in expected conservation MPT and other reduction methods provide for long-term conservation planning to ensure is to uncertainty from climate Coral Reef Conservation of the 50 coral reef regions a modern portfolio approach to expected conservation and risk of across the portfolio (Box 1). Reef have been to The of with the of the and The reefs the of and and resources around the portfolio of are by et Figure Conservation conservation the with a assessment to identify actions that are likely to conservation in the near to This assessment should be into local planning processes and at should provide capacity and and and for have been by a of L. Monitoring for Coastal in Coral Reef Monitoring Scholar, et is A for the of marine 2005; Scopus Google Scholar, S. et at World for Conservation and Sustainable are required for all limited coastal development, pollution, and climate change. The of habitat conservation (e.g., marine marine and reducing and coral reefs such as and heat capacity should to financial and capacity for of conservation and and natural This capacity assessment will key to such as financial to in capacity building for community to increase in reef and are to the long-term and of both and across should identify existing build a for future In this there are for from and with to strengthen and many regions et al.Coral reef habitat a of and Environ. 2018; Scopus Google Scholar]. The assessment of and should with a and that key for local and global to the long-term viability of and the of at and is for the long-term of coastal resources such as coral reefs. across the many has the potential to of scale and is needed in to the of change likely to be over the coming decades and century. MPT [15Anthony K. et al.New interventions are needed to save coral reefs.Nat. Ecol. Evol. 2017; 1: 1420-1422Crossref PubMed Scopus (138) Google Scholar] is a mathematical approach for building portfolios of assets that maximise the expected return for a given level of risk. The idea is built around the concept that the risk to an asset should be assessed in the context of the overall risk and return of all assets in a given portfolio. Variance-reduction methods are widely used in the financial sector, and MPT was part of the work for which Harry Markowitz received the 1990 Alfred Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Conservation planning is also fundamentally concerned with investing limited resources to achieve conservation outcomes (returns) while minimising the risk of failure of those projects. In the case of coral reef conservation, uncertainty in projected long-term conservation outcomes is driven by variation in estimates of climate change impacts. MPT provides a risk-sensitive framework for conservation planning that for the in expected outcomes planning et et planning for coral reef conservation under rapid climate Lett. 2018; Scopus Google Scholar] applied MPT to the of 50 coral reef at a global scale that are the least vulnerable to climate change and which have the potential to also regeneration in other There are impacts of climate on that are to with a of et used to past and projected ocean warming impacts and of as well as to other that the is across a range of of climate change to reduce risk in the while relatively of in expected conservation MPT and other reduction methods provide for long-term conservation planning to ensure is to uncertainty from climate change. conservation the with a assessment to identify actions that are likely to conservation in the near to This assessment should be into local planning processes and at should provide capacity and and and for have been by a of L. Monitoring for Coastal in Coral Reef Monitoring Scholar, et is A for the of marine 2005; Scopus Google Scholar, S. et at World for Conservation and Sustainable Scholar]. are required for all limited coastal development, pollution, and climate change. The of habitat conservation (e.g., marine marine and reducing and coral reefs such as and heat capacity should to financial and capacity for of conservation and and natural This capacity assessment will key to such as financial to in capacity building for community to increase in reef and are to the long-term and of both and across should identify existing build a for future In this there are for from and with to strengthen and many regions et al.Coral reef habitat a of and Environ. 2018; Scopus Google Scholar]. The assessment of and should with a and that key for local and global to the long-term viability of and the of at and is for the long-term of coastal resources such as coral reefs. across the many has the potential to of scale and is needed in to the of change likely to be over the coming decades and century. limited conservation both intervention and et approach to global conservation One. 2010; PubMed Scopus Google Scholar, et and conservation to coral One. 2010; PubMed Scopus Google Scholar]. Here, we a global strategy Figure in that on identifying coral reefs that have the best of projected climate change a below as in the Paris Agreement Working under the that the goals of the Paris Agreement will be achieved, these reefs are likely to play in the of corals as global average temperature by another and the regeneration of coral reefs in the context as ocean temperatures that the of change threats these reefs over this is of The identify coral reefs that are relatively less vulnerable to climate change are positioned to facilitate the regeneration of other reefs in the on the conservation we actions that threats (Box and Figure in the context of A recent et planning for coral reef conservation under rapid climate Lett. 2018; Scopus Google Scholar] applied modern portfolio to the of identifying a portfolio of reefs that has a as a of climate change while a capacity to other reefs over MPT is a mathematical approach for identifying an portfolio of such that the expected return on is for a given level of risk. MPT has been applied to planning and at a global scale portfolio to reduce conservation uncertainty in the S. 2012; PubMed Scopus Google Scholar, et risk in modern portfolio coastal planning under Appl. Ecol. 2018; Scopus Google Scholar]. In the context of long-term conservation risk from the uncertainty in the of future climate conditions. for the in conditions MPT the of a portfolio of Figure that are likely to provide return on with a risk of loss across the portfolio. MPT was used in this to the of a portfolio of 50 with to the reduced of to thermal stress in the past and future mass coral bleaching and and while also a of to other coral reefs. The large of the 50 (500 km2) the associated with while in the potential conservation interventions that be given in the and the of threats 2). this can in identifying and for conservation MPT are to is to all of a into a in all the of some of the by and et planning for coral reef conservation under rapid climate Lett. 2018; Scopus Google Scholar] in local conditions for conservation are In other may also be to be in a conservation the of a portfolio to that will be to based on local conditions and increased global political and of a global to the that climate change poses to coral reefs are to save coral reefs. the to ensure the of coral reefs also depends on the success of an of in across the The 50 large coral reef regions et planning for coral reef conservation under rapid climate Lett. 2018; Scopus Google Scholar] provide a portfolio of reefs that future climate stress and that in conservation global is needed to facilitate of the conservation and across the proposed portfolio (Box and Figure 2). will be the of threats such as habitat as well as the local to increasing climate threats such as heat stress and Sustainable conservation that the of and be into portfolio to reduce conservation uncertainty in the S. 2012; PubMed Scopus Google Scholar]. on a of on local 2). reducing coastal pollution by S.D. et and for on 2017; Scopus Google Scholar, et protecting the Great Barrier Reef from Change Biol. 2016; 22: PubMed Scopus Google Scholar], and et of community in of the 2016; Scopus Google Scholar], et increase resilience coral reef Lett. 2016; PubMed Scopus Google Scholar], reef with (e.g., J.E. et and of coral reef to climate One. 2013; PubMed Scopus Google Scholar]. conservation the of the of local and and other to strengthen the of these under the climate stress climate in conservation a and local that both and long-term conservation and goals 2). will of increased and human resources to the threats and local capacity many threats to coral reefs are coastal and and other and pollution and coastal the threats to coral reefs are at global 2016; Scopus Google Scholar]. While reefs need and conservation and the of threats for and and other regions that face The conservation of reefs also an approach to and that to identify and in of coral the by which such as climate change impact and and that these While the of et (2018) was to identify 50 coral reef regions with low to climate change and regeneration the also potential for and adaptation (e.g., et coral reef resilience S. PubMed Scopus Google Scholar]). may decades to the reduced ocean warming and risk may make these as of coral The of and et al.The need for ocean conservation in a Clim. Change. 2012; Scopus Google Scholar] may provide for many of these also with and is essential that of reef ecosystems be that we outcomes that coral reef conservation long-term in as well as conservation and development, will be required to these and The of the and strategy proposed is to ensure that coral reefs continue to provide and other key services for future the that these may be in many over the In a conservation planning a long-term that for projected in which is a that has been from planning In this the strategy and portfolio of 50 reefs are to and the many conservation efforts that are on coral reefs. This of should be as a of efforts that may have different goals (e.g., the and scales reefs less km2) are likely to be in the as the and of and scale a global strategy in can increase global political and and innovative into the conservation of the world’s coral reefs. In to scale up interventions across the portfolio of a in the global to the current decline of coral reefs is A recent by UN Environment that with recent is from such as to ensure the of the world’s coral reefs Environment (2018) Analysis of International Funding for the Sustainable Management of Coral Reefs and Associated Coastal Ecosystems. Coral Reef Initiative, UN Environment World Conservation Monitoring Centre. wcmc.io/coralbrochureGoogle Scholar]. The International Coral Reef has to be the International of the Reef and financing for this a boost to achieve its The recent of UN Sustainable and its to marine ecosystems is in of and action on coral reefs. the Reef at the in provides political for increased coral reef for action can conservation across the The portfolio approach et planning for coral reef conservation under rapid climate Lett. 2018; Scopus Google Scholar] is likely to also the of the and for coral reef conservation at global International including the Climate Environment and the level of they provide to coral reef in and efforts are required to ensure that the world’s coral reefs will persist into and beyond the O. Coral reefs in the the of the Scopus Google Scholar]. is of to coral reefs. The has been and is well in a that with and mass coral bleaching and across many [3Hughes T.P. et al.Global warming and recurrent mass bleaching of corals.Nature. 2017; 543: 373-377Crossref PubMed Scopus (1687) Google Scholar]. there is a need for global action and that are and if we are to the loss and global decline of coral The however, are upon the international community being to the goals of the Paris Climate reduction pledges are to the success failure of the are and in their current global temperatures beyond above the preindustrial if [7Rogelj J. et al.Paris agreement climate proposals need a boost to keep warming well below 2°C.Nature. 2016; 534: 631-639Crossref PubMed Scopus (1787) Google Scholar]. that these conditions will coral reefs for a hundreds of millions of and for action to greenhouse gas emission the Paris Climate Agreement and other and action on climate change the future is will be with of the world’s most and however, we have the to coral reefs in a there is that they will in a stable ocean and we human and ecosystem at coral reefs while also for the communities on there in finance (e.g., ecosystem that can be for and to the degradation of coral there for that reef up reef that are less vulnerable to climate change have been we human and ecosystem at coral reefs while also for the communities on there in finance (e.g., ecosystem that can be for and to the degradation of coral there for that reef up reef that are less vulnerable to climate change have been and are for from the the and the and was by an this and was a member of the for in Coral Reef the University of was by an this and was a member of the for for the University of the in which people the on the and that the rate of processes with the of into a such as of corals to natural to up a potential to overall heat to as in the current as approximately of coral which have to heat stress bleaching and and and are to systems. reefs to that are by corals that are to and which a community of international of at global while an international the framework of the to in at reducing climate change. the International Coral Reef as the International of the Reef with the that actions on local and global threats to coral reefs are with a reduced from of and of pollution from (e.g., by the international community to reduce greenhouse gas emissions as part of the Paris Climate also the Paris Climate Agreement, the part of the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) that is on reducing climate change greenhouse gas emissions and finance with a in the a to action to the and ensure that all people and on the those that are at a the decline over of is to this concept and the that can be from

References

26