Energy Research & Social Science · 2018 · 268 citations · 71 references
Public AffairsEnvironmental PolicyEnergy PolicyEnvironmental JusticeRegulatory Impact AssessmentEnergy JusticeEnvironmental Impacts Of ExtractionFossil Fuel PolicyFossil Fuel RegulationResource ExtractionTransboundary Environmental HarmEmbodied Energy AnalysisEnergy Infrastructure PoliticsFossil Fuel CombustionFossil Fuel DepletionFossil Fuel RegimesGlobal Environmental PoliticsTransboundary Impact ReportingTransboundary Risk Assessment
Embodied energy injustices reframe energy justice to consider hidden upstream and downstream harms from extraction, processing, transport, and disposal, illustrated by the Cerrejón coal mine powering Salem’s plant for a decade and Pennsylvania fracked gas fueling its replacement, yet regulatory frameworks ignore the diverse constituencies, jurisdictions, and effects beyond formal impact assessments. The authors introduce embodied energy injustices to promote transboundary assessment of energy policy, evaluate the injustices of decommissioning Salem’s coal plant and replacing it with natural gas, and call for mandatory transboundary impact assessments, expanded energy law, and solidarity movements to enhance governance and accountability. The study introduces embodied energy injustices and assesses the injustices of decommissioning Salem’s coal plant and replacing it with natural gas to encourage transboundary assessment of energy policy. Comparing coal and natural gas extraction reveals multiple parallel injustices.
We introduce the new concept of embodied energy injustices in order to encourage integrative, systemic, transboundary assessment of the global implications and responsibility of energy-policy decisions. Embodied energy injustices reframe considerations of energy justice to explicitly consider hidden and distant injustices (upstream or downstream) arising from the extraction, processing, transportation and disposal of energy resources. We assess the embodied energy injustices connected to the decision to decommission a coal-fired power plant in Salem, Massachusetts, US, and its replacement with a natural-gas-fired power station. Cerrejón open-pit coalmine in La Guajira, Colombia, powered the Salem plant for over a decade. Fracked gas from Pennsylvania now supplies fuel for the new power station. Comparing the extraction of these two very different fuels reveals multiple parallel injustices. But the regulatory environment fails to account for the different constituencies, jurisdictions and effects that fall outside the formal remit of existing impact assessments. We therefore call for mandatory transboundary impact assessments of large-scale energy-related projects, which explicitly integrate previously unrecognized social-environmental harms and injustices. Expanding energy law and policy discussions to incorporate embodied energy injustices can enhance sustainable energy governance and enable corporate accountability for the transboundary harms of fossil fuel extraction and use. Linking chains of energy injustice—by revealing their interconnected positions along fossil-fuel supply chains—may help generate and unite powerful trans-local solidarity movements, which politicize local struggles within wider national, regional and global energy politics.
71
Justice, Nature and the Geography of Difference
Kent Mathewson, David Harvey · Geographical Review · 1997 · 4.7K citations