Kepler’s Allegory of Containment, the Making of Modern Astronomy, and the Semiotics of Mathematical Thought

James J. Paxson

Intertexts · 1999 · 18 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Intcrtextt,Vo\. 3, No. 2,1999 Kepler's Allegory of Containment, the Making of Modern Astronomy, and the Semiotics of Mathematical Thought James J. Paxson U N I V E R S I T Y O F F L O R I D A That the German astronomer Johannes Kepler (1571-1630) is an allegorist comes as no surprise to anyone who has encountered his cryptic Somnium, atext largely finished by 1610, added to for some twenty years, and published posthumously in 1634 by Kepler's son Ludwig. Aclever book which speculates about the astronomical perspective of dwellers on the moon, the Somnium seu Astronomia Lunari, as it was fiilly tided, summedupKepler'slifelonginterestsindreamlore,symbolism,demonol¬ ogy, the mystical value of geometry, and medieval literature.Aresolute be¬ liever,alongwithGalileoorNewtonorBoyle,thatthephysicalcosmoswas thescriptofGod,Keplerwassteepedaswellinclassicalliteramreevenin hisadult,professionallife.WhenhearrivedinthecityofGrazin1594to teach arithmetic to the adolescent sons of the well-to-do at the Protestant Stiftsschule,healsotaughtrhetoricandthepoetryofVergilbecausehis mathematicallectureswereunpopularandundersubscribed(Caspar5657 );likewise,hislettersseempepperedwithintense,oftenoverwrought mytJiographic metaphors. iAs Graz school authorities in charge of Kepler s teachingassignmentsclaimedandasKeplerbiographerMaxCasparquotes, "mathematicsisnoteveryone'smeat"(56).ButKepleralsohadtropes,fig¬ ures, and myth in his very bones. MyobjectinthisessayistoplaceKeplerwithinthegenealogyofthe great European allegorists, the genealogy containing Mamanus Capella, BernardusSilvestris,Dante,andChaucer.Aconsummatepractitionerof literaryallegory,thegreatastronomercraftedoneofthemostcompelling otherworldlyjourneysinliterature.Buthisallegory,Ibelieve,capturesfar thanthehermeneuticallyencryptedlawsofthenewphysicsorthehe¬ liocentricastronomy.Kepler'sSomniumencapsulatesorincorporatestopoi from anumber of his theoretical writings, proffering what can be thought of as anarratology or "allegory of containment," an imagined geometry bothfiguralandliteral,textualandthematic.Atthesametime,itcon¬ ductsaparableofcognitiveormeta-discursiveself-reflection.Thatis,the Somnium yields itself up best, first, when studied through contemporary narratologicaltechnique—^withspecialfocusonthenarratologicalmaster tropeofembeddingorframing—andsecond,onceitisunderstoodasan allegorynotonlyaboutspeculationsconcerningspaceandheavenlybodies m o r e 1 0 5 1 I N T E R T E X T S 1 0 6 but also about the very psychic or cognitive mechanisms by which the 1 mathematical or scientific investigator could be said to produce mathemat- : ics and science. The narrative stmcture of the Somnium is self-re nishing arelentless "narrative of narrative" (Williams 24). With all of alle¬ gory's attendant tropes and figural mechanisms, the text reflects upon mathematicalcognitionitself,acognitionform^zedeventuallybythe American semiotician C. S. Peirce and his twentieth-century successor, Brian Rotman—both of whom, Iwill argue, are prefigured in Kepler's many-leavedallegoryofscienceandnarrative. My highlighting of Kepler's "allegory of containment" will thus bypass hismajorcontributions(theAstronomianovaortheHarmonicemundi) and focus on some minor texts, such as the Somnium—perh toe cosmic allegories of the Latin Middle Ages—as well as the ea A^sterium cosmographicum (1596) and Nova stereometria (1615). Whereas the Mysterium tends to be disparaged in the positivist sketches of philoso- .^®toryofsciencebecauseofitsearlinessanditsunabashedabstract| ^^^t)nism,2 the Nova stereometria or Stereometria Doliorum Vinariorum (TheMeasurementofWineCasks")receivespraiseforitsroleinthe '^^^ftoent of seventeenth-century mathematics. Yet both brief texts cmatize an allegory of geometry, aprocess that finds recipr tauon in the geometry of allegory presented in Kepler's Crete nanative of the ^ ^ .pier's Somnium has often been thought of as the first work ern science fiction. It is ajuncture text, marking the start of d me ung speculative science fiction, modern astrophysics, an C" *^tasy. To say that it is adream vision in which the narrator grasps radi¬ cal scientific knowledge is to seU it short. It does stand in the tradition of Artemidoms'Oneirocritica,Cicero'sdreamofScipio,Macrobius'commentatyonthatdream ,andChaucer'sTheHouseofFame,afamousMiddle English allegory which likewise involves the dream of an ascent into aethenal space punctuated by avisit to an insula, aplanet-like "island," ^lengthy lecture given by apersonified ma^ister (a talking, goeneagle)whoimpartsthesecretsofphysics,particularlywhatwas tothefourteenthcenturyaboutacousticsandwavephenomena (Chaucer348-73).ButKepler'sSomniumis,literallyandfiguratively, wrappedinshellsandlayersofnarratologicalcomplexitythatrender mentary on it, let alone mere summary of it, far more difficult. Kepler begins the Somnium with the claim that he's been reading lots ofBohemianhistorybecauseofapoliticaldisputeinlocallands.Hefalls asleep one night while reading about aheroic woman from the Middle Ages, Libussa, and he recounts how, in adream, he buys an old book at market which contains the personal account of an Icelandic astronomer named Duracotus. But Duracotus, after recounting his own early life with his mother Fiolxhilde, asorceress, and abrief training period received in adolescence from the historical Tycho Brahe (Kepler's own true idol). c o m J 1 0 7 Paxson—Kepler's Allegory of Containment repeats along lecture told him by an unnamed Daemon who travels back and forth regularly to the moon, which is called Levania by its inhabitants...