Spreading the (Fake) News: Exploring Health Messages on Social Media and the Implications for Health Professionals Using a Case Study

S Sommariva, Cheryl A. Vamos, Alexios Mantzarlis, Lillie Uyên-Loan Đào, Dinorah Martinez Tyson

American Journal of Health Education · 2018 · 229 citations · 29 references

Concepts

TL;DR

Social networking sites are widely recognized as platforms for correcting fake news, yet further evidence is needed to understand the popularity of health‑related rumors and how health educators can best leverage these platforms. This study aimed to examine how health rumors and verified information about Zika spread on social networking sites. Researchers conducted a three‑phase content analysis of Zika‑related news stories on social networking sites from February 2016 to January 2017, first verifying accuracy, then measuring share volume, and finally performing a thematic analysis of headlines. The analysis revealed that health rumors about Zika were shared three times more than verified stories, portrayed the virus as a low‑risk conspiracy linked to pesticides, and highlighted the need for targeted communication strategies to counter misinformation and support disease‑prevention efforts by health educators.

Abstract

Background: The importance of social networking sites (SNSs) as platforms to engage in the correction of “fake news” has been documented widely. More evidence is needed to understand the popularity of health-related rumors and how Health Educators can optimize their use of SNSs. Purpose: The purpose of this study was to explore the spread of health rumors and verified information on SNSs using the Zika virus as a case study. Methods: A content analysis of Zika-related news stories on SNSs between February 2016 and January 2017 was conducted to verify accuracy (phase 1). Phase 1 was followed by an analysis of volume of shares (phase 2) and a thematic analysis of headlines (phase 3). Results: Rumors had three times more shares than verified stories. Popular rumors portray Zika as a conspiracy against the public and a low-risk issue and connect it to the use of pesticides. Discussion: This study identifies the value of integrating in-depth analysis of popular health-related rumors into the development of communication strategies. Translation to Health Education Practice: Misinformation on SNSs can hinder disease prevention efforts. This study shows how information circulating on SNSs can be analyzed from a quantitative and qualitative standpoint to help Health Educators maximize the use of online communication platforms.

References

29