European Journal of Social Theory · 2018 · 58 citations · 13 references
HumanitiesPathologyPhilosophyPhilosophy Of BiologySocial CognitionSocial PhilosophyHuman ConditionSocial ScienceNaturalist CharacterizationSocial Ontology
This article starts with the idea that the task of social philosophy can be defined as the diagnosis and therapy of social pathologies. It discusses four conceptions of social pathology. The first two conceptions are ‘normativist’ and hold that something is a social pathology if it is socially wrong. On the first view, there is no encompassing characterization of social pathologies available: it is a cluster concept of family resemblances. On the second view, social pathologies share a structure (e.g. second-order disorder). The last two conceptions are ‘naturalist’ and hold that something is wrong because it is pathological. The third view takes it that society is the kind of substance that can fall ill – an organism. The fourth view operates with the notion of a social life that can degenerate. The four conceptions are compared along six criteria: (1) is the view plausible?; (2) is it informative (if true)?; (3) does it help define the task of social philosophy?; (4) does it take naturalistic vocabulary seriously?; (5) does it hold that pathologies share a structure?; and (6) how does it see the primacy of being wrong and being pathological?
13
Alice Ambrose, Ludwig Wittgenstein, G. E. M. Anscombe · Philosophy and Phenomenological Research · 1954 · 12.3K citations
Freedom of the Will and the Concept of a Person
Harry G. Frankfurt · The Journal of Philosophy · 1971 · 4.4K citations
The normal and the pathological
Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A · 1991 · 309 citations
Medicine, Pathology, Physiology +15
Interpretation and Social Criticism
Bernard Rosen, Michael Walzer · The Journal of Higher Education · 1988 · 265 citations