Journal of the Intensive Care Society · 2018 · 41 citations · 20 references
MedicineHealth LawHealth PolicyBioethicsEthicsMedical EthicsConsentDeceased Donor CareDonor SelectionOrgan ProcurementTransplant EthicsTransplantation EthicsCadaveric Donation ConsentCadaveric Organ DonationDonor Informed ConsentExplicit ConsentOpt-in Organ DonationOpt-in PoliciesOpt-out Organ DonationPresumed Consent
The near-universal acceptance of cadaveric organ donation has been based on the provision of explicit consent by the donor while alive, either in the form of a formal opt-in or informal discussion of wishes with next of kin. Despite the success of transplantation programmes based on explicit consent, the ongoing imbalance between demand and supply of organs for transplantation has prompted calls for more widespread introduction of laws validating presumed consent with facility for opt-out as a means of increasing organ availability. The Department of Health (UK) has recently concluded a consultation on the introduction of such a law for England. This article explores the debate on presumed consent from an ethical point of view and summarises the key arguments on both sides of the ethical divide.
20
John Harris · Philosophy · 1975 · 230 citations · Full text
The case for “presumed consent” in organ donation
Ian Kennedy, R A Sells, Daar As et al. · The Lancet · 1998 · 131 citations