Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies · 2004 · 310 citations · 0 references
HumanitiesReligionReligious StudiesAncient HistoryAsian StudiesCosmologyAncient ChinaAncient CosmologyAsian ReligionsChinese ReligionsChinese StudiesImperial ChinaAncient Chinese HistoryDivination SpeechShang Dynasty
Early Chinese thought was marked by a long‑standing debate over the relationship between humans and gods, with one view treating the realms as separate and antagonistic and another seeing them as related, allowing humans to attain divinity, a tension often overlooked in monistic interpretations. The book aims to reconstruct this debate and situate the rival claims about cosmology, the human–divine boundary, and the powers of humans and spirits within their contemporary contexts. It does so by employing a wide‑ranging historical and comparative analysis of Shang oracle bones, memorials, and other sources to examine cosmological and sacrificial arguments. The study finds that ancient Chinese cosmological assumptions were far more contested than previously thought, revealing significant debate over human–divine relations.
Evidence from Shang oracle bones to memorials submitted to Western Han emperors attests to a long-lasting debate in early China over the proper relationship between humans and gods. One pole of the debate saw the human and divine realms as separate and agonistic and encouraged divination to determine the will of the gods and sacrifices to appease and influence them. The opposite pole saw the two realms as related and claimed that humans could achieve divinity and thus control the cosmos. This wide-ranging book reconstructs this debate and places within their contemporary contexts the rival claims concerning the nature of the cosmos and the spirits, the proper demarcation between the human and the divine realms, and the types of power that humans and spirits can exercise. It is often claimed that the worldview of early China was unproblematically monistic and that hence China had avoided the tensions between gods and humans found in the West. By treating the issues of cosmology, sacrifice, and self-divinization in a historical and comparative framework that attends to the contemporary significance of specific arguments, Michael J. Puett shows that the basic cosmological assumptions of ancient China were the subject of far more debate than is generally thought.