The Family Planning Effort Index: 1999 2004 and 2009.

John A. Ross, Ellen Smith

2010 · 17 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Context National programs to extend family planning to large populations began in the mid-1960s and now exist in most developing countries. They vary greatly in strength and coverage as well as in the nature of their outreach. Periodic measures of their types and levels of effort have been conducted since 1972 showing increasing strength. These measures have been used as the only consistent assessment of program efforts for all countries over time. They have served to inform policy positions and resource allocations as well as technical analyses of program impact on contraceptive use and fertility declines. Methods Questionnaires completed by 10-15 expert observers in each of 81 countries score 30 measures of effort each on a scale from 1 to 10. Additional measures assess four general program characteristics. The 81 countries encompass 93 percent of the developing world population and all of the largest countries in each region. Results The latest measures show that the average program effort level has again increased although by a small amount. Program effort as either a weighted or unweighted average across the developing world increased slightly from 1999 to 2004 and again in 2009. Policy positions are rated highest; service arrangements and actual access to contraceptive methods are rated well below that. The Asian region receives the highest scores and dominates the global averages due to China India Bangladesh Pakistan and Indonesia. However all regions contain great diversity among country scores. Within the sub-Saharan Africa region focus countries of the U.S. President’s Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief (PEPFAR)1 are of particular interest as are historical differences between Anglophone and Francophone countries. On another subject there are systematic differences between USAID population assistance “graduated countries” most other Latin America countries and severely disadvantaged countries. Conclusions Average program effort levels remain robust in general despite concerns about diversion of resources to HIV/AIDS donor fatigue and other problems. However average effort is still only at about half of the maximum or about two-thirds of the level attained by the strongest countries. The profile of effort across the 30 indicators remains essentially the same as before but with sharp differences across the indicators and considerable selectivity in the contraceptive methods stressed. Regional differences remain much as before with Asia strongest sub-Saharan Africa weakest and Latin America in between. Within sub-Saharan Africa differences have narrowed considerably between Anglophone and Francophone countries and PEPFAR countries in the Anglophone group show similar trends to non-PEPFAR countries whether due to their dissimilar histories or to other factors. “Graduated” countries2 outperformed comparison countries during much of the past but differences since 1999 are small between them and the comparison countries (most of Latin America). Separate questions in 2004 and 2009 show that program justifications rest more heavily on health than on fertility reduction but adolescent and postabortion emphases rate rather low. Donor and domestic funding changes have been unfavorable-much more so than other influences such as the merging of family planning programs into broader health services.