Poor reproductive success of Gray Vireos in a declining California population

Lori Hargrove, Philip Unitt

Journal of Field Ornithology · 2017 · 11 citations · 36 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Since the 1940s, populations of Gray Vireos (Vireo vicinior) in California have collapsed, presumably because of parasitism by Brown-headed Cowbirds (Molothrus ater). In 2012 and 2013, we studied the vireo's nesting ecology to assess factors affecting two of California's largest remaining populations in the chaparral of San Diego County. Nest success was extremely low, with a model-averaged probability of nest survival of only 0.08 (N = 95). More nest failures were due to predation (83%) than to cowbird parasitism (13%). Video-recording at 30 nests revealed that California Scrub-Jays (Aphelocoma californica) were the most common nest predator (67%). Of eight variables tested, height of shrubs surrounding the nest had the strongest negative influence on nest survival, but was more strongly correlated with cowbird parasitism than with jay predation. Despite frequent renesting, seasonal productivity was well below the level required to sustain a population, especially in northern San Diego County where we found no Gray Vireos at six of seven sites where they had been present from 1997 to 2001 and where cowbird parasitism was more frequent. The vireo's continuing range collapse contrasts with recent climate-change models predicting a range expansion, highlighting the importance of demographic studies. Low nest success is likely contributing to population declines in California, and the additive effect of cowbird parasitism suppresses productivity. Conservation of Gray Vireos in California will likely require development of alternative approaches to cowbird and scrub-jay control appropriate to sites widely scattered in rugged chaparral. Desde la década de 1940, las poblaciones de Vireo vicinior en California se han desplomado, presuntamente por el parasitismo por Molothrus ater. En 2012 y 2013, estudiamos la ecología de anidación de Vireo vicinior, con el objetivo de determinar los factores que afectan las dos poblaciones más grandes de California en el chaparral del condado de San Diego. El éxito reproductivo fue extremadamente bajo, con una probabilidad promedio de supervivencia del nido de solo 0.08 (N = 95). La mayor cantidad fracasos de nidos fue producto de depredación (83%) y no de parasitismo por Molothrus ater (13%). Grabaciones de 30 nidos revelaron que el depredador más común fue Aphelocoma californica (67%). De las ocho variables evaluadas, la altura de los arbustos alrededor del nido tuvo la influencia negativa más fuerte sobre la supervivencia del nido, sin embargo, estuvo más fuertemente correlacionada con el parasitismo por parte de Molothrus ater que por la depredación por parte de Aphelocoma californica. A pesar de los intentos frecuentes de re-anidación, la productividad estacional fue considerablemente menor al nivel requerido para sostener una población, especialmente en el norte del condado de San Diego, donde no encontramos Vireo vicinior en seis de las siete localidades donde había sido reportado entre 1997 y 2001, y donde el parasitismo por Molothrus ater fue más frecuente. La reducción actual de la distribución de Vireo vicinior difiere con los modelos recientes de cambio climático que predicen una expansión de la distribución, resaltando la importancia de estudios demográficos. Es probable que el éxito reproductivo bajo contribuya a la disminución en las poblaciones de California, y el efecto aditivo del parasitismo de Molothrus ater suprima la productividad. La conservación de Vireo vicinior en California requerirá del desarrollo de métodos alternativos para el control de Molothrus ater y Aphelocoma californica que sean apropiados para localidades muy dispersas en chaparral escabroso. Gray Vireos (Vireo vicinior) are one of the least-studied birds in North America (Barlow et al. 1999) and populations are inadequately monitored by existing programs, e.g., data from Breeding Bird Surveys are insufficient for trend analysis (https://www.pwrc.usgs.gov/bbs). However, because of their limited range, local extirpations, and presumed susceptibility to parasitism by Brown-headed Cowbirds (Molothrus ater), Gray Vireos have been identified as a species of conservation concern since 1978 (Remsen 1978, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service 2008). In most of their breeding range, Gray Vireos occur in pinyon-juniper woodlands, but they are found in arid chaparral in California's Transverse and Peninsular ranges (Unitt 1984). These areas tend to be remote and largely protected in national forests. Although habitat availability does not appear to be a limiting factor, Gray Vireos occur patchily at low densities in California (1.2–1.6 birds per 40 ha; Johnson et al. 1948, Weathers 1983) and elsewhere (Corman 2005, DeLong and Williams 2006, Schlossberg 2006, Wickersham and Wickersham 2008). Populations in California once represented a substantial proportion of the known range of Gray Vireos, but they appear to have declined precipitously, probably by 75–95% (Supplemental Fig. S1; Remsen 1978, Unitt 2008, Hargrove and Unitt 2014). California's largest known population, estimated at 960 birds in the San Jacinto Mountains by Grinnell and Swarth (1913), is now nearly extirpated even though the habitat appears intact (Hargrove and Unitt 2014). Recent records in California are few and scattered except in two regions of San Diego County that appeared, as of 2002, to have the two largest populations, with numbers estimated in the low hundreds (Unitt 2004). Cowbird parasitism has been suggested as the reason for the decline of the Gray Vireo population in California (Remsen 1978), but empirical support is limited (Hanna 1944, Friedmann 1963), and the prevalence of cowbird parasitism in the arid chaparral used by Gray Vireos is unknown. Other factors such as nest predation could also be contributing to the decline, perhaps interactively with cowbirds, as reported for other species (e.g., Stumpf et al. 2011). Although reasons for the decline of California populations of Gray Vireos are unclear, their current status calls for monitoring and identification of current threats. Thus, our objectives were to document the nesting ecology and status of Gray Vireos in California, determine if cowbirds are a primary cause of nest failure, and identify other factors influencing nest success and seasonal productivity. To evaluate the current status of Gray Vireos in California, we targeted two areas of the Cleveland National Forest in San Diego County with most of California's remaining population as of 2001 (Unitt 2004): one north of Warner Springs (North County; 33°20′N, 116°38′W) and one 50 km south in the southern Laguna Mountains (South County; 32°47′N, 116°28′W) (Supplemental Fig. S1). Based on field work conducted from 1997 to 2001 (Unitt 2004), we identified seven sites most likely to be occupied in the North County study area and 12 in South County, representing at least 50% of the recorded sites and most of the known population in the county. We surveyed these 19 sites to determine current occupancy and to identify plots for monitoring. At sites where Gray Vireos were apparently absent, we resurveyed the site and other intervening habitat at least twice during May and early June 2012 and 2013 to confirm absence. In South County where we had estimated territory density by spot-mapping in two areas of ~250 ha each in 2002, we repeated that effort in 2012 for comparison (Hargrove and Unitt 2014). To document nesting ecology and nest outcomes, we defined plots for intensive monitoring based on the area we could cover effectively in 4–5 h and the presence of Gray Vireos. One occupied site in the South County study area was too difficult to access so could not be included in our study. Lack of trails, rugged terrain, and thick vegetation limited plot size to 20–50 ha. At elevations from 1000 to 1500 m, plots were heterogeneous in shrub structure and composition, but dominated by chamise (Adenostoma fasciculatum; Fig. 1). To ensure a minimum sample of 30 territories monitored per year and 10 nests video-monitored per year, we surveyed 13 study plots in 2012 and nine of the same plots in 2013. Considerable searching in 2012 of the seven sites occupied in North County from 1997 to 2001 revealed Gray Vireos at only one, restricting us in that region to two adjacent study plots surveyed in both 2012 and 2013. The remaining plots were in South County (11 plots in 2012, and 7 in 2013). At all plots, we mapped territories and monitored nests from first arrival of Gray Vireos (late March) to after the last active nest (late August). We searched each territory 2–3 times per week for evidence of nesting and fledging. We found most nests by observing pairs either carrying nest material or frequently returning to the same shrub. No adults were banded, but we were able to delineate territory boundaries because males sang nearly continuously during the day (including while on nests) and neighboring males often sang simultaneously. Boundaries of defended territories (mean area = 11 ha, range = 5–18 ha) changed little within and between years. We typically checked nests every 2–5 days (mean = 2.9 days, range = 1–8 days). Confirming the date the first egg of a clutch was laid or, in some nests, whether eggs were ever laid was not always possible because birds sat tightly on nests beginning even before eggs were laid. Thus, instead of flushing birds from nests, we more often observed from a distance and checked nest contents when adults left nests. We were able to estimate the date of laying of first eggs to within 3 days for 93% of nests (mean = 1.2 days, range = 0–6 days). We excluded from analysis nests that were incomplete or nests where, because of a lack of subsequent incubation, we suspected no eggs were laid. We also recorded clutch sizes (after clutches were completed), final nest outcomes, and number of fledglings. For any nests with young near fledging age and a we as to confirm fledging and fledglings. nests or young we between and shrubs are to variables with nest and surrounding We identified nest and nest height and shrub height and a of 3 of each we estimated shrub cover of the from and of all We by 3 from nests and the proportion of each nest from at each of and the nests were or the sample size for some and we not data for of of nests because intact nests were for For any we the from all other nests. To surrounding we also shrub height and shrub cover within 3 m, and shrub height within 3 at by study In each study plot with at least Gray Vireo we by within the and any within of a Gray Vireo nest or At these we the shrub within the range of at Gray Vireos To shrub at nests and surrounding we analysis and based on species or of species species as For of each of these we used the cover estimated within a at each nest as well as at Based on the the first represented a of from chamise to and the from (Adenostoma to to species for each are the To evaluate any of year on nest success and seasonal we the in the of our study and a to 2013). We and minimum and at from the We the data for were from in North County and elevations and in South We monitored 30 nests in 2012, 10 in in eight plots with for a of as as nest and after was recorded but we checked nests with on the same as to confirm nest contents and the of In to predation and also the of our of the of and We for any influence of on nest by survival of nests with and and their at nest We our to be to and able to continuously between of and every The of a with a in in a a a a and a to the and were with their in to be more to a and were and for were to a of either the nest shrub or adjacent shrub from nests and that were also and a the and was in a at least 7 from nests. on nests during but within if typically but to were as and to for We estimated the that nests day nest and that nests from first egg to fledging nest by number of days To the influence of variables on nest survival, we used and et al. 2004), to a of models all possible additive of eight variables = by and For each we the all models that for a of the importance and 2002, and et al. models were by and we for the of models of was no more than than that of the and 2002, We estimated nest survival, nest survival, and of variables by of the For each we the model-averaged estimate based on the that and the that for in as well as due to in and 2002, and 2011). The eight variables were year = or 2013 = date of first egg to for the date study area (South = or North = nest shrub = or other = nest nest and height and cover of shrubs within a of 3 of nests. We height as a because was correlated with the height of both the nest and surrounding Of the remaining eight between any two were We each nest as because territories were and habitat variables were limited to than between nests in neighboring territories were than between nests in the same and cowbirds were present in every and birds were not We used to other For and nest we and a for For analysis of and all other we used and to be We estimated seasonal productivity as a range by the minimum and numbers of possible per study area and by the number of was defined as the number of observed and as the number of observed during the final nest are as Gray Vireos were observed on the first date in both 2012 March) and 2013 during the first two of In both was a between arrival and nesting We monitored 40 territories in 2012 and of same territories in 2013. date of egg laying in 2013 was days than in 2012 = but was no effect of study area = = and no between year and study area = = laying also in 2013 The fledging of was on 2012 and 12 2013. We territories in but our were on 12 2012 and 10 2013. nests we nests in 2012 and 40 in 2013 = nests per Of the nests, most were found to egg and the within eight days of egg nests pairs nests in as little as one nests likely before we could but we observed at least six nesting in a in one each nests the number of days between a nest and egg laying in a nest was (N = range = days). clutch size was eggs in 2012, = and in 2013, = range = = For one nest with only one we the young Based on the 10 nests (Supplemental Fig. the to of the first was days = and the to fledging of the first was days = days). For the two the nest was at least days but typically was days (Supplemental Fig. We one of with the first fledging on June and the on 12 a from the first nest from the as eggs in the and in the territory after young from the nest nests (N = were in chamise and height of nest shrubs was (N = range = nest height was 1.2 (N = range = height of shrubs within 3 of nests was (N = range = cover of shrubs within 3 was (N = range = and nest was (N = range = nests were on (mean = = = and of nests were from the of the or of shrubs (mean = = = At least one young from of nests Of nests, at least 10 were by Brown-headed two nests in one nests were with adults in six nests (83%) because of or probable 50 during egg laying or incubation, eight near or and seven during the nests had the eggs by cowbirds, but we these as nests likely because of evidence and one nest was after probable of the the was observed on nests where we observed no eggs were apparently and were excluded from our Of 30 nests young from were by cowbirds, two because of and eggs found were probably not recorded or and were Of these nests, California Scrub-Jays (Aphelocoma californica) eggs from 10 nests a on at one nest (Supplemental a at one a eggs at one and on eggs at one nest and at California Scrub-Jays were the most frequent predator of = The nests were after with cowbirds (e.g., from only two of nests in North County (e.g., and from of nests in South County. to be by a in the of cowbird in North County and in South County = The of surrounding shrub with nest but of study to and nests, nests to be more strongly near chamise and The between on of chamise to of nests and nests to any between study areas (North County South County but of nests that because of and cowbirds More nests were in 2013 than in 2012 because of parasitism and predation were and than the but 2013 was than 2012 in 2013 was below were in 2013 the influence on and with the between of nests and of the nest survival was for nests with and for nests the possible of one where a scrub-jay to a nest h after we found no either between and to predation or between nest and to predation. Based on from all possible of variables surrounding shrub nest study and surrounding shrub cover were more in predicting nest survival than year, species of nest and nest models were within of the = Based on the model-averaged estimate was for nest survival and 0.08 for nest in the at least and model-averaged for each the based on from all models surrounding shrubs had a negative effect on nest survival, nest height had a effect We also the height of shrubs and all nests, as well as Although surrounding shrubs to be nests than 2.9 = = we found no in between nests and nests that because of either scrub-jay predation or cowbird parasitism 1.2 = = Although clutch size was the number of per nest was only either on minimum number of or on on the last nest Thus, all a of territories we estimated that seasonal productivity was between and per territory in North County, and in South of 19 sites with records of Gray Vireos during field work for the San Diego County Bird Unitt revealed Gray Vireos at 11 of 12 sites in South County, but at only one of seven sites in North County. of intervening habitat in North County revealed no of the two sites in South County where we mapped Gray Vireo territories in (Hargrove and Unitt revealed a decline from to six territories the at and a decline from 10 territories to one at south that not nest success and nest success of Gray Vireos in the arid chaparral of California were than reported elsewhere within their The success of Gray Vireo nests in pinyon-juniper in by and in et al. 1999) was and in pinyon-juniper in from to Wickersham and reasons for in nest success the range of Gray Vireos are unclear, but low nesting success is likely contributing to population declines in Nest success was especially low in our North County study area where more have during the years. Despite frequent renesting, seasonal productivity during the two of our study was below that to sustain populations in our two study of both and Gray Vireos is but et al. estimated survival probability of adults of other species of the at and survival is likely at the estimated seasonal productivity of Gray Vireos in our South County study area and the estimated survival, the population was productivity per of = survival probability of productivity typically be because both of our study were but nest survival was in the year and clutch size was in both years. Thus, our that any substantial in seasonal productivity of Gray Vireos require a in of nest predation or that the range of Gray Vireos with a et al. National to declines in California, more is in demographic have in some areas and but are and populations appear to be and the For Gray Vireos were observed in only of in from to (Corman only birds were at on the of and in 2001 and the estimated population at known sites in from to birds in and Williams 10 nests by cowbirds in our study were but most nests due to by California was frequent because Gray Vireo nests were more likely to at early in all 10 of scrub-jay predation by eggs than The range of the range of Gray Vireos, but their densities be in southern California than in other as suggested by the Breeding Bird for birds per in southern California in other Although not the primary cause of nest failure, cowbird parasitism to seasonal productivity. reported for other cowbirds could also to nest either by eggs or (e.g., et al. and et al. or by (e.g., Stumpf et al. 2011). Brown-headed Cowbirds California to declines in other species to parasitism (Unitt 2008). of Gray Vireos elsewhere have been reported as low to with frequent (Barlow et al. of with success of the Gray Vireo nests we studied were of vegetation with a proportion of chamise and surrounding nest sites could both and cowbirds by the number of from a nest is more likely to be and In other of the range, has not been but Schlossberg found that Gray Vireo territories were with and more with other especially However, in pinyon-juniper in Johnson et al. found that Gray Vireos apparently nest sites where were and than in In our study nests were more strongly with a proportion of a possible for more cover of chamise or a of chamise and that tend to in height and cover surrounding be negative in cover of as in more where for species the probability of parasitism as distance to the (e.g., et al. for chamise could also of predation by that are typically with in California 2004). However, we found little in any between nests by and nests. Gray Vireos have been studied little so our of factors in their conservation is we as for factors that influence of nest predation by alternative of cowbird and the ecology of Gray Vireos. In California, are strongly with because are of their at least May 2004). the nest success of other but and found that the with their of nest predation. Thus, predation by could be in with of et al. In from and that their and and and so are in the Gray habitat of arid chaparral with few be from nest predation be by to eggs with and in nests the year, a used with elsewhere and 2014). monitoring of Gray Vireo populations also monitoring of scrub-jay populations to determine the of and factors influencing the at nests. In with nest predation by the additive effect of parasitism be especially in our North County study area where the Gray Vireo population is more and parasitism was more common than in South County To the productivity of cowbird control has been if local parasitism for two or more et al. and However, the and of Gray Vireo the low population and the limited number of cowbirds that be from we not cowbird for the of the Vireo to be for Gray Vireos. or cowbirds with of recorded calls and et al. areas where we studied Gray Vireos had within the last 40 but had within the last 10 years. that be for the However, in the the and size of in region have and are to be and more to et al. et al. 2008, et al. 2008, et al. 2008). Gray Vireos are observed from sites of known breeding or that site (Barlow et al. 1999) with their to to sites as the habitat A from the California of Fish and Wildlife and a from the Cleveland National Forest to and for work was by and and with the development of the to the of and for data from their of Gray Vireos. to and for on early of the and to of the final The is not for the or of any by the than be to the for the

References

36