Medical Physics · 2017 · 22 citations · 42 references
MedicineOncologyRadiation OncologyDiagnostic ImagingRadiation DosimetryTreatment PlanningComputed TomographyComputed Tomography PhysicsMonte Carlo DosimetryRadiation TherapyRadiation Treatment PlanningTreatment Planning Dose CalculationAnisotropic Analytical AlgorithmsImaging-based DosimetryPencil Beam ConvolutionRadiotherapy Dose PlanningRespiratory Motion CorrectionStereotactic Body Radiotherapy DosimetryStereotactic Dose CalculationStereotactic Treatment Planning
Purpose Inhomogeneity dose modeling and respiratory motion description are two critical technical challenges for lung stereotactic body radiotherapy, an important treatment modality for small size primary and secondary lung tumors. Recent studies revealed lung density‐dependent target dose differences between Monte Carlo (Type‐C) algorithm and earlier algorithms. Therefore, this study aimed to investigate the equivalence of the two most popular CT datasets for treatment planning, free breathing ( FB ) and average intensity projection ( AIP ) CT s, using Type‐C algorithms, and comparing with two older generation algorithms (Type‐A and Type‐B). Methods Twenty patients (twenty‐one lesions) were planned using a Type‐A algorithm on the FB CT . Lung was contoured separately on FB and AIP CT s and compared. Dose comparison was obtained between the two CT s using four commercial dose algorithms including one Type‐A (Pencil Beam Convolution – PBC ), one Type‐B (Analytical Anisotropic Algorithm – AAA ), and two Type‐C algorithms (Voxel Monte Carlo – VMC and Acuros External Beam – AXB ). For each algorithm, the dosimetric parameters of the target ( PTV , D min , D max , D mean , D95, and D90) and lung (V5, V10, V20, V30, V35, and V40) were compared between the two CT s using the Wilcoxon signed rank test. Correlation between dosimetric differences and density differences for each algorithm were studied using linear regression and Spearman correlation, in which both global and local density differences were evaluated. Results Although the lung density differences on FB and AIP CT s were statistically significant ( P = 0.003), the magnitude was small at 1.21 ± 1.45%. Correspondingly, for the two Type‐C algorithms, target and lung dosimetric differences were small in magnitude and statistically insignificant ( P > 0.05) for all but one instance, similar to the findings for the older generation algorithms. Nevertheless, a significant correlation was shown between the dosimetric and density differences for Type‐C and Type‐B algorithms, but not for the Type‐A algorithm. Conclusions With the capability to more accurately model inhomogeneity, Monte Carlo (Type‐C) algorithms are sensitive to respiration‐induced local and global tissue density changes and exhibit a strong correlation between dosimetric and density differences. However, FB and AIP CT s may still be considered equivalent for dose calculation in the Monte Carlo era, due to the small magnitude of lung density differences between these two datasets.
42
Stereotactic Body Radiation Therapy for Inoperable Early Stage Lung Cancer
Robert Timmerman · JAMA · 2010 · 2.5K citations · Full text
4D-CT imaging of a volume influenced by respiratory motion on multi-slice CT
Tinsu Pan, Ting-Yim Lee, Eike Rietzel et al. · Medical Physics · 2004 · 620 citations
Acquiring 4D thoracic CT scans using a multislice helical method
Paul Keall, George Starkschall, H Shukla et al. · Physics in Medicine and Biology · 2004 · 398 citations
Joern Wulf, Ulrich Haedinger, Ulrich Oppitz et al. · International Journal of Radiation Oncology*Biology*Physics · 2004 · 351 citations
Thomas G. Purdie, Jean‐Pierre Bissonnette, K. Franks et al. · International Journal of Radiation Oncology*Biology*Physics · 2007 · 348 citations