Taking a stance on emotion: affect, sequence, and intersubjectivity in dialogic interaction

John W. Du Bois, Elise Kärkkäinen

Text and Talk · 2012 · 278 citations · 0 references

Concepts

TL;DR

The paper examines affect and emotion in interaction, focusing on stance, sequence, and dialogicality, and highlights how sequence shapes stance realization and dialogic resonance aligns subsequent stances. The study aims to frame affective display within how participants collaboratively construct socioaffective and sociocognitive relations that organize intersubjectivity through stance taking. The authors draw on conversation analysis and sociocultural linguistics to view stance as a triplex act of evaluation, positioning, and alignment, using overt communicative means to construct affect, emotion, and intersubjectivity. The authors argue that alignment functions as a continuous variable, with participants subtly monitoring and modulating stance differentials while maintaining strategic ambiguity, and they highlight the special issue’s contributions to stance, affect, and intersubjectivity research.

Abstract

Abstract This paper explores the domain of affect and emotion as they arise in interaction, from the perspective of stance, sequence, and dialogicality. We seek to frame the issue of affective display as part of a larger concern with how co-participants in interaction construct the socioaffective and sociocognitive relations that organize their intersubjectivity, via collaborative practices of stance taking. We draw mainly on two research traditions, conversation analysis and the dialogic turn in sociocultural linguistics, focusing on their treatments of affect, emotion, and intersubjectivity. Key ideas from the respective approaches are the role of sequence in shaping the realization and interpretation of stance, and dialogic resonance as a process of alignment between subsequent stances. We present a view of stance as a triplex act, achieved through overt communicative means, in which participants evaluate something, and thereby position themselves, and thereby align with co-participants in interaction. Alignment is argued to operate as a continuous variable rather than a dichotomy, as participants subtly monitor and modulate the “stance differential” between them, while often maintaining a strategic ambiguity. Finally, we comment on the rich contributions to the study of stance, affect, and intersubjectivity in interaction made by the collaborators in this special issue.