Comparing electricity transitions: A historical analysis of nuclear, wind and solar power in Germany and Japan

Aleh Cherp, Vadim Vinichenko, Jessica Jewell, Masahiro Suzuki, Miklós Antal

Energy Policy · 2016 · 180 citations · 81 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

TL;DR

The paper compares the evolution of nuclear, wind, and solar power in Germany and Japan to understand national variations in low‑carbon electricity use, developing a framework that analyzes transitions through techno‑economic, political, and socio‑technical interactions. The framework analyzes low‑carbon electricity transitions by examining the interplay of techno‑economic, political, and socio‑technical processes. The study finds that while Germany and Japan followed similar low‑carbon paths in the 1970s–1980s, Germany has since led in renewables and phased out nuclear, whereas Japan has expanded nuclear power and lagged in renewables, a divergence driven by Japan’s rapid electricity demand growth and energy insecurity, Germany’s easier wind diffusion, and a weakened nuclear regime amid coal and renewable competition, with five mechanisms identified that may apply to other transitions.

Abstract

This paper contributes to understanding national variations in using low-carbon electricity sources by comparing the evolution of nuclear, wind and solar power in Germany and Japan. It develops and applies a framework for analyzing low-carbon electricity transitions based on interplay of techno-economic, political and socio-technical processes. We explain why in the 1970s–1980s, the energy paths of the two countries were remarkably similar, but since the 1990s Germany has become a leader in renewables while phasing out nuclear energy, whereas Japan has deployed less renewables while becoming a leader in nuclear power. We link these differences to the faster growth of electricity demand and energy insecurity in Japan, the easier diffusion of onshore wind power technology and the weakening of the nuclear power regime induced by stagnation and competition from coal and renewables in Germany. We show how these changes involve the interplay of five distinct mechanisms which may also play a role in other energy transitions.

References

81