When breath becomes air

Henry Marsh

Brain · 2016 · 97 citations · 0 references

DOIFull text

Open access

Concepts

Abstract

Many doctors, as they approach old age, observe that it is only when they themselves, or members of their family, fell ill and became patients that they really understood what the patients whom they had treated had had to go through. Paul Kalanithi wrote When Breath Becomes Air while he was waiting to die from metastatic lung cancer. It is, however, much more than just another tragic life story or the memoirs of a cancer victim—literary forms that are currently very popular—as Kalanithi was a young neurosurgeon who was just on the point of completing his training when his cancer was diagnosed. As with many doctors with cancer—who often deny their symptoms—it was some time before the diagnosis was made. He dismissed his back pain—caused by secondary disease in his spine—as being benign. He recounts the months of treatment, and the difficult limbo of prolonged remission, which modern medicine can now give us. We are treated but not cured and must learn to live with a slow death sentence. He movingly describes the negotiation between hope and acceptance of death, and the complexity of discussions with your oncologist, as different chemotherapy treatments provide only temporary reprieve, and become increasingly toxic. The balance between hope and resignation becomes increasingly difficult to judge. He died at the age of 37 before …