Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology · 2016 · 32 citations · 37 references
NursingBehavioral SciencesPsychologyInterpersonal CommunicationPsychophysiologyStress PhysiologyFeedback CommunicationSocial StressArousal EffectsArousal StatesControl Group DesignEmotional EffectsFeedbackMatched Control GroupPsychophysiological ArousalPsychophysiological Mechanisms
Previous studies have found that communicating acceptance and understanding (validation) enhances the recipient's psychological and physiological wellbeing compared with receiving nonunderstanding feedback (invalidation). Yet, such studies have not established whether it is validation or absence of invalidation that is beneficial. This study examined the social, physiological, and emotional effects of validating and invalidating feedback in more detail, by employing a control group. Ninety healthy volunteers were randomly allocated to receive validating, invalidating, or no feedback during a series of stressor tasks. Self-report ratings, psychophysiological measurements and social engagement behaviors were recorded. While there were no significant differences between validated and control participants, invalidated participants showed increased physiological and psychological arousal on several measures and reduced social engagement behaviors compared with the other two groups. The relevance of these findings for understanding adverse effects of invalidation during clinical interactions is discussed.
37
The Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale
A. S. Zigmond, R. P. Snaith · Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica · 1983 · 46.6K citations
Kim L. Gratz, Lizabeth Roemer · Journal of Psychopathology and Behavioral Assessment · 2003 · 8.7K citations
Roy F. Baumeister, Ellen Bratslavsky, Catrin Finkenauer et al. · Review of General Psychology · 2001 · 7.4K citations · Full text
John R. Crawford, Julie D. Henry · British Journal of Clinical Psychology · 2004 · 3K citations · Full text