The Journals of Gerontology Series A · 2016 · 118 citations · 18 references
MedicineGeriatric MedicineRehabilitation MedicineAssistive TechnologyGeriatric AssessmentPhysical ActivityFunctional Assessment In Older AdultsGait AssessmentPhysical Activity AssessmentPhysical Performance AssessmentActivity MonitoringBland-altman PlotIntraclass CorrelationMissed Step DetectionOlder Adult Physical Activity AssessmentPhysical Activity MonitoringWearable Activity MonitoringWearable Activity Monitors
The accuracy of step detection in consumer-based wearable activity monitors among older adults with diverse ambulatory abilities is unknown. This study evaluated the validity of two hip‑worn (Fitbit One, Omron HJ‑112) and two wrist‑worn (Fitbit Flex, Jawbone UP) activity monitors in 99 older adults with varying mobility, comparing them to the ankle‑worn StepWatch. Participants (62+ years) with nonimpaired, impaired, cane‑using, or walker‑using status walked 100 m at a self‑selected pace while wearing all monitors, with step counts directly observed as the criterion and assessed via ICC, percent error, equivalency, and Bland–Altman analyses. StepWatch, Omron HJ‑112, Fitbit One, and Jawbone UP accurately measured steps in nonimpaired and impaired adults, with StepWatch also accurate for cane users, whereas the wrist‑worn Fitbit Flex consistently underestimated steps by >26 % and had poor ICCs (<0.15).
The accuracy of step detection in consumer-based wearable activity monitors in older adults with varied ambulatory abilities is not known. We assessed the validity of two hip-worn (Fitbit One and Omron HJ-112) and two wrist-worn (Fitbit Flex and Jawbone UP) activity monitors in 99 older adults of varying ambulatory abilities and also included the validity results from the ankle-worn StepWatch as a comparison device. Nonimpaired, impaired (Short Physical Performance Battery Score < 9), cane-using, or walker-using older adults (62 and older) ambulated at a self-selected pace for 100 m wearing all activity monitors simultaneously. The criterion measure was directly observed steps. Intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC), mean percent error and mean absolute percent error, equivalency, and Bland–Altman plots were used to assess accuracy. Nonimpaired adults steps were underestimated by 4.4% for StepWatch (ICC = 0.87), 2.6% for Fitbit One (ICC = 0.80), 4.5% for Omron HJ-112 (ICC = 0.72), 26.9% for Fitbit Flex (ICC = 0.15), and 2.9% for Jawbone UP (ICC = 0.55). Impaired adults steps were underestimated by 3.5% for StepWatch (ICC = 0.91), 1.7% for Fitbit One (ICC = 0.96), 3.2% for Omron HJ-112 (ICC = 0.89), 16.3% for Fitbit Flex (ICC = 0.25), and 8.4% for Jawbone UP (ICC = 0.50). Cane-user and walker-user steps were underestimated by StepWatch by 1.8% (ICC = 0.98) and 1.3% (ICC = 0.99), respectively, where all other monitors underestimated steps by >11.5% (ICCs < 0.05). StepWatch, Omron HJ-112, Fitbit One, and Jawbone UP appeared accurate at measuring steps in older adults with nonimpaired and impaired ambulation during a self-paced walking test. StepWatch also appeared accurate at measuring steps in cane-users.
18
Jack M. Guralnik, E. M. Simonsick, Luigi Ferrucci et al. · Journal of Gerontology · 1994 · 9.7K citations