1984 · 48 citations · 39 references
Natural SciencesToxicologyAquatic ToxicologyEcotoxicologyEnvironmental ToxicologyAquatic EcotoxicologyEcotoxicological Risk AssessmentSpecies Differences In ToxicitySpecies SensitivityAquatic Toxicity TestingEcotoxicity TestingPositive Predictive ValuePositive Predictive Value EstimationSpecies Dose-response ComparisonsSpecies Sensitivity AnalysisSpecies Sensitivity VariabilityToxicity Assessment
Aquatic organisms differ in their sensitivity to chemicals, which contributes to the uncertainty in estimates of toxicity with respect to aquatic life. Based on an examina tion of acute toxicity data from the literature, maximum variation in sensitivity between and within organism groups was shown to be similar, approximately four orders of magnitude. An effort was made to quantify the ability of single test systems as well as test batteries to predict the response of other aquatic species. It was found that the predictive value of a test battery increases with size and that the combination of test organisms included in the battery also affects predictive value. It was further shown that the risk of significantly underestimating toxicity with respect to aquatic life is considerable also when using test batteries consisting of up to five or six members. The use of a predictivity factor (analogous to the application factor) is suggested to compensate for the underestimation of toxicity due to the species dependent variation in sensitivity. The implications of the results on the design and evaluation of proposed test strategies are briefly discussed.
39