Medical Law Review · 2015 · 34 citations · 0 references
LawHealth LawHuman Rights LawHealth Care LawHealthcare LawMedical EthicsHealthcare Abuse LawsStandard Of CareEthical Justification Of CoercionEthical Limits Of Coercion
Coercive care remains predominant in the treatment of mental ill health.It is distinctive as one of the very few areas of medical practice where overtly paternalistic traditions still dominate, and patients can be admitted compulsorily to hospital and forcibly treated, irrespective of their mental capacity or individual autonomy.Undoubtedly, the use of coercion in this way is 'hotly 'contested' (p.5), particularly in an era where patient autonomy and human rights are increasingly at the forefront.Inevitably, this creates tension and forces us to re-examine conventional approaches to the treatment of mental ill health, and this edited collection seeks to do just that.Contributors to this collection explore the concept of coercion and present a challenge to it as a legitimate way of providing care to mentally ill individuals.The advent of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities (CRPD) has provided further impetus to this challenge.The CRPD clarifies the obligations on State Parties to promote and ensure the rights of persons with disabilities.To date, it has 159 signatories, including most of the jurisdictions which are considered in this edited collection. 1 Significantly, the CRPD adopts a social model of disability, viewing people with disabilities as subjects who deserve equal recognition and respect.This approach stands in contrast to the medical model, which views people with disabilities as objects who are afflicted by their illness and require protection and sympathy.The medical model strongly influenced the United Nations Principles for the Protection of Persons with Mental Illness, which were adopted in 1991, and are now regarded by many as outdated and inappropriate, focusing as they do on treatment and protection.The new CRPD rights-based approach posits that disabilities are the result of barriers created by society, 'the social model of disability locates the experience of disability in the social environment, rather than the impairment'. 2Consequently, there is a need for signatories to the CRPD to take 'action to dismantle the social and physical barriers to the inclusion and participation of persons with disability '. 3