Psychology Health & Medicine · 2016 · 31 citations · 11 references
Social SciencesBehavioral SciencesPsychologyExercise PsychologyHealth PsychologyPhysical ActivityBreathing ExercisesPlacebo EffectAffectControl Group DesignExercise Outcome ExpectanciesExercise ParticipantsFramed Field ExperimentsMatched Control GroupPsychological Benefits Of ExerciseWell-being
Outcome expectancy could mediate the psychological effects of exercise-related interventions, which implies that part of the psychological benefits of physical activity could be ascribed to placebo effects. In this framed field-experiment, 89 healthy participants were studied in three groups, (1) breathing-primed (deep-breathing with an exercise-related expectancy), (2) breathing-unprimed (deep-breathing with no exercise-related expectancy), and (3) control (no intervention). Deep-breathing lasted for three minutes. Before and after deep-breathing, or sitting quietly in the control group, participants completed two questionnaires assessing their positive- and negative affect (NA) and subjective well-being (WB). In contrast to the control group, both the breathing-primed and breathing-unprimed groups showed decreased NA and increased subjective WB. The breathing-primed group reported larger changes in WB than the breathing-unprimed group, in addition to also exhibiting significant increases in positive affect. These findings support the hypothesis of the work that expectations mediate the psychological effects of deep-breathing beyond the intervention's specific effects. Therefore, future research should control for expectations related to an intervention when gauging psychological changes.
11
Ravinder Jerath, John W. Edry, Vernon A. Barnes et al. · Medical Hypotheses · 2006 · 551 citations · Full text
Camille B. Wortman, Robert Rosenthal, Ralph L. Rosnow · The American Journal of Psychology · 1976 · 432 citations