Zimbabwe's Militarized, Electoral Authoritarianism

Eldred V. Masunungure

Journal of international affairs · 2011 · 46 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

Authoritarianism in Zimbabwe survives because a coalition of political and military elites stands ready and willing to employ violence to execute Machiavellian vision of President Robert Mugabe and perpetuate his control of state. Several variables reinforce durability of this regime--chief among them mass out-migration and large inflow of remittances that has decimated middle class and dampened political voice of those who remain in country. Beginning in 2000, Zimbabwe's authoritarianism became militarized with overt intrusion of security sector into political arena, a process that reached its peak before June 2008 presidential runoff election. The dimension of its authoritarianism stems from fact that regime unfailingly holds elections in search of popular legitimacy but then manipulates them for its own ends. This article dissects Zimbabwe's militarized form of authoritarianism with specific reference to 2008 reign of terror. It concludes that factor that best explains regime is symbiosis between party and security sector, with Mugabe providing glue that binds them together in pursuit of regime survival ********** Many one-party and dominant-party regimes survived demise of Soviet era despite broad sweep of modern political Among survivors was Zimbabwe. (1) This article focuses on case of Zimbabwe with specific reference to country's elections in 2008 and factors that played critical roles in maintenance of political regime. It argues that security factor looms larger than other explanations, but also brings into equation variables that work to cushion regime but that are not intrinsic to it. EXPLAINING THE PHENOMENON OF AUTHORITARIAN DURABILITY Authoritarian durability is not a new political phenomenon, nor is it a dying one. The euphoria generated by collapse of many seemingly robust one-party and dominant-party regimes overshadowed preceding interest in studies of authoritarianism to a point where the end of twentieth century witnessed a proliferation of studies of democracy and democratization. (2) Thomas Carothers notes that a dominant characteristic in last quarter of twentieth century was simultaneous movement in at least several countries in each region away from dictatorial rule toward more liberal and often more democratic governance. (3) Indeed, implosion of Soviet Union led some scholars to triumphantly declare the end of and global victory of liberal democracy. For instance, Francis Fukuyama declared that we had reached the end point of man kind's ideological evolution and universalization of Western liberal democracy as final form of human government. (4) But end-of-history triumphalism was quickly dampened by return of history when authoritarianism found ways of mutating under new conditions. Instead of brutally suppressing liberal-democratic institutions, dictators manipulated them. Thus, Carothers observes that the widely hailed wave of democratization that washed over [sub-Saharan African] region in early 1990s has ended up producing many dominantpower systems. (5) Andreas Schedler concurs, detecting the startling spread of multiparty elections without democracy, and explains: The new stars in constellation of nondemocratic governance are electoral authoritarian regimes, which conduct regular multiparty elections at all levels of government yet violate basic democratic standards in serious and systematic ways. What happened? This question has confounded many and lies at core of puzzle about resilience of authoritarianism in its many subtypes, especially in era of Several schools of interpretation have emerged to account for this puzzle. …