Neurology · 2016 · 78 citations · 25 references
MedicineNeurologyNeurosurgeryGeriatric AssessmentGeriatric CareNeurocritical CareAcute Stroke ManagementCerebrovascular Emergency CareNeurologic PrognosticationPrognostic AssessmentStrokeSubarachnoid Hemorrhage ManagementGlasgow Coma Scale PrognosticationIntracerebral Hemorrhage CareIntracerebral Hemorrhage PrognosticationNeurological Outcome PredictionPhysician Treatment IntensityPrognostic Grading ScalesPrognostic Score ValidationSubarachnoid Hemorrhage Prognostication
OBJECTIVE: To assess physician prognosis and treatment recommendations for intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH) and to determine the effect of providing physicians a validated prognostic score. METHODS: A written survey with 2 ICH scenarios was completed by practicing neurologists and neurosurgeons. Selected factors were randomly varied (patient older vs middle age, Glasgow Coma Scale [GCS] score 7T vs 11, and presence vs absence of a validated prognostic score). Outcomes included predicted 30-day mortality and recommendations for initial treatment intensity (6-point scale ranging from 1 = comfort only to 6 = full treatment). RESULTS: A total of 742 physicians were included (mean age 52, 32% neurosurgeons, 17% female). Physician predictions of 30-day mortality varied widely (mean [range] for the 4 possible combinations of age and GCS were 23% [0%-80%], 35% [0%-100%], 48% [0%-100%], and 58% [5%-100%]). Treatment recommendations also varied widely, with responses encompassing the full range of response options for each case. No physician demographic or personality characteristics were associated with treatment recommendations. Providing a prognostic score changed treatment recommendations, and the effect differed across cases. When the prognostic score suggested 0% chance of functional independence (76-year-old with GCS 7T), the likelihood of treatment limitations was increased (odds ratio [OR] 1.61, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.12-2.33) compared to no prognostic score. Conversely, if the score suggested a 66% chance of independence (63-year-old with GCS 11), treatment limitations were less likely (OR 0.62, 95% CI 0.43-0.88). CONCLUSIONS: Physicians vary substantially in ICH prognostic estimates and treatment recommendations. This variability could have a profound effect on life and death decision-making and treatment for ICH.
25
Paul A. Harris, Robert Taylor, Robert J. Thielke et al. · Journal of Biomedical Informatics · 2008 · 51.7K citations · Full text
Michael F. Scheier, Charles S. Carver, Michael W. Bridges · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology · 1994 · 5.8K citations
Michael F. Scheier, Charles S. Carver, Michael W. Bridges · Journal of Personality and Social Psychology · 1994 · 5.7K citations
Guidelines for the Management of Spontaneous Intracerebral Hemorrhage
J. Claude Hemphill, Steven M. Greenberg, Craig S. Anderson et al. · Stroke · 2015 · 4K citations
Medicine, Neurology, Neurosurgery +12
J. Claude Hemphill, David C. Bonovich, Lavrentios Besmertis et al. · Stroke · 2001 · 2.2K citations
Medicine, Neurology, Neurosurgery +17