An Investigation of the Reporting of Questionable Acts in an International Setting

Joseph J. Schultz, Douglas A. Johnson, Deigan Morris, Sverre Dyrnes

Journal of Accounting Research · 1993 · 255 citations · 27 references

Concepts

TL;DR

A questionable act is defined as a violation of justice, honesty, or economy, aligning with auditing standards on internal control violations, illegal acts, and financial statement irregularities, and recent U.S. laws emphasize the need for auditor detection when such acts evade internal controls. The study develops a framework to assess managers' and professionals' likelihood of reporting questionable acts domestically and internationally, and offers preliminary evidence of its usefulness. Initial evidence indicates the framework effectively evaluates reporting propensity.

Abstract

This study provides a framework for examining corporate managers' and professionals' propensity to report questionable acts in both the domestic and international contexts, and presents initial evidence on the usefulness of the framework. A questionable act is defined in this paper as an action which violates a standard of justice, honesty, or economy (Graham [1986, p. 2]). This definition is consistent with the external auditing literature's conceptions involving violations of internal control (SAS No. 55, AICPA [1988c]), illegal acts (SAS No. 54, AICPA [1988b]), and intentional financial statement errors (irregularities) (SAS No. 53, AICPA [1988a]). Because the need for auditor detection of such acts arises only if the acts elude the corporation's internal control system, recent U.S. laws and official guidance urge strengthening

References

27