Bodily Irruptions: The Corporeal Assault on Ethnographic Narration

Jennifer M. Barker

Cinema Journal · 1995 · 15 citations · 6 references

Concepts

Abstract

In 1972, at the invitation of the Chinese government, director Michelangelo Antonioni embarked on a twenty-two-day documentary production in that country. Traveling north to south, from Beijing to Shanghai, Antonioni and his crew sought to capture the images and sounds of everyday life in the People's Republic. The resulting film, Chung Kuo China, engages in a fascinating negotiation of the terms and conventions of ethnography as a Western scientific enterprise and of the narrative strategies on which that enterprise depends. These negotiations, which occur throughout the body of the film, manifest themselves in one particular sequence, during which the crew arrives at a small village near Hunan whose inhabitants have never come in contact with a movie camera. The camera and crew are led into the village by a state-appointed guide and interpreter who, according to the voice-over narrator (the source of all objective information in this sequence, as throughout most of the film), explains to the townspeople the event about to happen. Meanwhile, the narrator describes the reaction of the Chinese villagers to the filming event as one of uncertainty, curious suspicion, and fear. The sequence unfolds in a series of medium long shots and medium close-ups of the villagers staring directly at the camera; initially they watch, unmoving, from curbs and doorways, but in later shots they begin to walk away from the camera, exiting into alleys, around corners, even, as one boy does, peering from behind the architecture. Over these shots the voice-over narrates their experience, describing the fear that makes them run away and hide. In fact, the voice-over seems to impose that fear onto this behavior; we have no indication that the townspeople's leaving the scene is not the result of waning interest or boredom (there is nothing to suggest that the crew had not been filming all day!), rather than the fear of uncivilized people faced with Western technology for the first time. The contradiction between the bodies of the Chinese, their physical behavior, and the reading of that behavior offered by the narrator comes to a head in the final shot of the sequence, in which a villager approaches the camera, about to walk past the crew. The narrator continues to speak of fear and doubt while the villager, staring directly into the camera, provides a physical challenge to that interpretation; this man is clearly not afraid.

References

6