The Effects of Lobbying: a Comparative Assessment

Harmon Zeigler

The Western Political Quarterly · 1969 · 10 citations · 0 references

Concepts

Abstract

ADHERENTS of the group theory of politics would consider it heretical to wonder what would happen to the legislative process if there were no groups and lobbyists. Yet, such a question is not unreasonable, especially when one considers the fact that most case studies of interest groups in action begin with the assumption that the group model is correct. However, recent studies of the lobbying process in Washington, notably those of Milbrath and Bauer, Pool, and Dexter, suggest that the policy outcomes of Congress would not have been very different if lobbyists were eliminated from the decision-making process.' The serious questions raised by these studies need further exploration on a comparative basis. If it is true that lobbyists are not very influential in Washington, why is this so? One would suspect that there are certain structural conditions in Washington, not the least of which is that the legislator has other sources of information, that reduce the influence of lobbyists. The purpose of the research reported here is to offer an assessment of the strength of groups in four states: Massachusetts, North Carolina, Oregon, and Utah.2 The theoretical focus of the study centers around the concept of interaction. We need to know: (1) how much interaction between legislators and lobbyists actually takes place; (2) what is the nature of this interaction; and (3) what is the effect of this interaction. Finally, having offered an assessment of the effects of interaction, it is necessary to speculate as to possible explanations for variations in effect. This is a difficult task, and any number of explanations might be as valid as the one suggested in the conclusion to this article. Nevertheless, a beginning of a revised theory of the role of groups in the political process should offer some speculation as to why groups are powerful in some systems and not in others. Of course, one can argue that the political systems themselves, rather than the interaction of participants within these systems, is the crucial explanatory factor. Taking this approach, one might link the strength of groups to the economic, social, and political characteristics of a state. It will be necessary to consider this argument after first presenting an alternative explanation.